📖 Overview
A young girl waits impatiently for the arrival of her baby cousin Gregory. Her aunt's pregnancy prompts endless questions about babies and childbirth, which her family members answer with creative and whimsical explanations.
The girl's relatives share stories about where babies come from - tales involving watermelon seeds, special orders from catalogs, and mysterious deliveries. Throughout her wait, she learns about family traditions and the different ways people welcome new life into the world.
Through the girl's innocent questions and her family's imaginative responses, the story explores childhood curiosity and the bonds between generations. The narrative celebrates how families use storytelling and humor to handle children's big questions about life.
👀 Reviews
Most readers find this picture book confusing, with several online reviews noting that children struggle to follow the story's premise of various family members offering different explanations for a baby's delayed arrival.
Readers appreciate:
- The warm family dynamics
- Bagram Ibatoulline's detailed illustrations
- The anticipation theme resonates with children expecting siblings
Common criticisms:
- The narrative structure loses young audiences
- Too abstract for the intended age group
- Multiple metaphors overcomplicate a simple concept
Ratings across platforms:
Goodreads: 3.5/5 (based on 130 ratings)
Amazon: 3.8/5 (based on 10 reviews)
One parent reviewer on Amazon notes: "My 4-year-old couldn't follow all the different explanations and lost interest." A librarian on Goodreads comments: "The illustrations are beautiful but the story might work better for adults than children."
The book receives stronger reviews from adults who appreciate its creative approach than from parents reading it with young children.
📚 Similar books
All The Small Poems and Fourteen More by Valerie Worth
A collection of deceptively simple poems captures quiet moments and everyday objects through a child's perspective.
The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros Short vignettes tell the story of a young girl's life through snapshots of her neighborhood, family, and growing awareness of the world.
The Thing About Luck by Cynthia Kadohata A Japanese-American girl navigates family obligations and cultural expectations while her parents work away from home.
Each Little Bird That Sings by Deborah Wiles A young girl from a family of funeral home directors learns about life and loss through her connections with family and community.
Pearl Verses the World by Sally Murphy A story told in verse follows a girl processing changes in her family while finding her voice through poetry.
The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros Short vignettes tell the story of a young girl's life through snapshots of her neighborhood, family, and growing awareness of the world.
The Thing About Luck by Cynthia Kadohata A Japanese-American girl navigates family obligations and cultural expectations while her parents work away from home.
Each Little Bird That Sings by Deborah Wiles A young girl from a family of funeral home directors learns about life and loss through her connections with family and community.
Pearl Verses the World by Sally Murphy A story told in verse follows a girl processing changes in her family while finding her voice through poetry.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Author Kimberly Willis Holt drew from her own life experiences growing up in a military family, moving frequently between Louisiana, Guam, and Paris, France
📚 The story explores family relationships through multiple perspectives, weaving together the excitement of waiting for a new baby with the wisdom of older generations
🎨 The book's illustrations, created by Gabi Swiatkowska, use a dreamy, ethereal style that captures the anticipation and wonder of waiting for a new family member
👶 The narrative addresses the common childhood experience of waiting for a new sibling, but takes a unique approach by focusing on an aunt's perspective rather than a direct sibling
🏆 Kimberly Willis Holt is a National Book Award winner for her novel "When Zachary Beaver Came to Town," bringing her acclaimed storytelling style to this picture book