Past Obsessions: World War Two in History and Memory

Past Obsessions examines how World War II has been remembered, commemorated, and contested across different societies and time periods. Through analysis of memorials, media, museums, and public discourse, Carol Gluck traces the evolution of WWII memory from 1945 to the present. The book moves between major nations involved in the conflict, comparing how the war shaped national identities and historical narratives in places like Japan, Germany, Russia, and the United States. Gluck analyzes key moments and sites of memory, from the Tokyo War Crimes Trials to Holocaust memorials, showing how interpretations of the war have shifted over generations. The work draws on extensive research in multiple languages and disciplines, incorporating perspectives from history, anthropology, and cultural studies. Gluck examines both official state narratives and grassroots memory movements, revealing the complex interplay between public and private remembrance. By exploring how different societies process traumatic pasts, Past Obsessions offers insights into the relationship between memory, identity, and power in the modern world. The book demonstrates how World War II continues to influence contemporary politics and international relations through competing interpretations of its meaning and legacy.

There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Carol Gluck's overall work: Readers value Gluck's thorough research and clear analysis of Japanese history, particularly in "Japan's Modern Myths." Academic reviewers highlight her detailed examination of how Japan constructed its national identity. What readers liked: - Clear explanation of complex historical concepts - Extensive use of primary sources and original documents - Balanced perspective on sensitive historical topics - Strong citation practices What readers disliked: - Dense academic writing style that can be difficult to follow - Heavy use of specialized terminology - Some sections repeat information - High price point for academic texts Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 4.1/5 (42 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (12 ratings) One PhD student reviewer noted: "Her analysis of Meiji period ideology formation is unmatched in English-language scholarship." A common criticism from undergraduate readers was that the text requires significant background knowledge of Japanese history to fully appreciate. Most reviews come from academic sources, with fewer general reader reviews available.

Cultures of War by John W. Dower This work examines how cultural narratives and memory shaped perspectives of World War II, Pearl Harbor, and 9/11 in both American and Japanese societies.

The World War Two Reader by Gordon Martel The collection brings together key historical documents and scholarly interpretations that demonstrate how World War II has been remembered and reinterpreted across different nations and time periods.

Hiroshima in History and Memory by Michael J. Hogan The book analyzes the complex ways in which the atomic bombing of Hiroshima has been interpreted, memorialized, and debated in both Japan and the United States.

The War Complex: World War II in Our Time by Marianna Torgovnick The text explores how World War II continues to influence contemporary culture through memory, media, and historical interpretation.

Wartime: Understanding and Behavior in the Second World War by Paul Fussell The work examines the gap between the public memory of World War II and the actual experiences of those who lived through it.

🌟 Carol Gluck coined the term "Showa synthesis" to describe Japan's post-war narrative that positioned the Japanese people as victims rather than aggressors in WWII 📚 The book explores how different nations have created competing and often contradictory memories of World War II, with particular focus on Japan, Germany, and the United States 🏛️ Much of the research for Past Obsessions was conducted while Gluck was the George Sansom Professor of History at Columbia University, where she has taught Japanese history since 1975 🗣️ The work examines how public memory of WWII has been shaped by various forces including government policies, education systems, popular media, and museums 🌏 Gluck challenges the notion of a single "historical truth" about WWII, demonstrating how national memories are constantly revised and reconstructed to serve present-day political and social needs