Generations of Feeling: A History of Emotions, 600-1700

Generations of Feeling traces emotional experiences and expressions across medieval and early modern Europe through extensive analysis of historical texts. The book examines how different communities and time periods developed their own emotional styles, vocabularies, and norms. Through case studies spanning 1100 years, Rosenwein analyzes emotional communities ranging from early medieval monasteries to Renaissance courts. Her research encompasses theological writings, medical treatises, letters, chronicles, and literary works to reconstruct how people understood and navigated feelings in their social contexts. The work challenges assumptions about medieval emotional life being less sophisticated than modern experiences. Rosenwein demonstrates that historical communities had complex systems for understanding, expressing, and regulating emotion that evolved over time. This ambitious study connects emotion history to broader questions about human nature and social change. The book makes the case that examining historical emotional styles helps illuminate how societies structure feeling and meaning.

Readers describe this as a dense academic text that requires patience and background knowledge in medieval history. Multiple reviews note Rosenwein's thorough research across a millennium of emotional concepts and communities. Likes: - Clear organization by time period and emotional community - Detailed analysis of how emotions were understood differently across eras - Strong evidence from primary sources and texts - Useful for scholars studying history of emotions Dislikes: - Writing style is dry and technical - Assumes substantial knowledge of medieval history - Some sections are repetitive - Limited accessibility for general readers One reviewer on Academia.edu appreciated the "meticulous attention to linguistic and contextual details," while a Goodreads review criticized the "overwhelming amount of specialized terminology." Ratings: Goodreads: 4.17/5 (12 ratings) Amazon: Not enough reviews for rating Google Books: No ratings available Review counts are limited since this is primarily an academic text rather than a mainstream book.

The History of Emotions: An Introduction by Jan Plamper This examination of emotions throughout history traces the development of emotional theories from ancient philosophy through modern neuroscience.

What is an Emotion? Classic and Contemporary Readings by Robert C. Solomon The collection presents primary sources and philosophical texts about emotions from ancient Greece to contemporary thought.

Reading the Early Modern Passions: Essays in the Cultural History of Emotion by Gail Kern Paster, Katherine Rowe, and Mary Floyd-Wilson The text explores how emotions were understood and expressed in European society between 1500-1800 through analysis of literature, art, and medical texts.

Fear: A Cultural History by Joanna Bourke This cultural history tracks the manifestation and understanding of fear from the nineteenth century to the present through medical documents, personal accounts, and social movements.

The Navigation of Feeling: A Framework for the History of Emotions by William Reddy The book presents a theoretical framework for studying emotions in history through examination of emotional standards in Revolutionary and post-Revolutionary France.

🔹 The author traces how medieval people experienced and expressed emotions through detailed analysis of emotion words in texts from different time periods - revealing that concepts like "happiness" or "anger" meant very different things in different centuries. 🔹 Rather than viewing medieval emotional expression as more primitive or less controlled than modern feelings, Rosenwein demonstrates that medieval people had sophisticated emotional vocabularies and complex ways of understanding their inner lives. 🔹 The book examines emotional communities across time - from early medieval monasteries to royal courts to merchant households - showing how different social groups developed their own distinctive emotional styles and norms. 🔹 Many emotion words we consider basic today, like "sad" or "disgusted," either didn't exist or meant completely different things in medieval times. The word "sad" originally meant "satisfied" or "steadfast." 🔹 Rosenwein revolutionized the study of medieval emotions by developing the concept of "emotional communities" - groups that share norms about the expression and value of different feelings. This framework is now widely used by historians.