📖 Overview
Martha Nell Smith's Comic Power in Emily Dickinson examines the often-overlooked humorous elements in Dickinson's poetry and letters. The book presents an analysis of Dickinson's wit, wordplay, and comedic sensibilities through close readings of her work.
The study draws extensively from Dickinson's correspondence and manuscript materials, revealing the poet's engagement with humor as both a social and literary device. Smith analyzes Dickinson's relationships with family, friends, and correspondents through the lens of her comic expressions.
Smith challenges traditional views of Dickinson as solely a reclusive, melancholy figure. Her research demonstrates how Dickinson used comedy as a tool for social connection and artistic innovation.
The book contributes to Dickinson scholarship by highlighting the intersection of humor, gender, and power in nineteenth-century American literary culture. Through this exploration of comic elements, readers gain new perspectives on Dickinson's artistic complexity and social engagement.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Martha Nell Smith's overall work:
Readers cite Smith's work as influential in reshaping Dickinson scholarship, particularly through her manuscript-based research and digital humanities approach. Her books provide detailed analysis backed by primary source evidence.
What readers liked:
- Clear presentation of archival materials and correspondence
- Thorough documentation of Dickinson's relationship with Susan Huntington Dickinson
- Integration of digital tools with traditional literary analysis
- Accessible academic writing style for both scholars and general readers
What readers disliked:
- Some found the theoretical frameworks overly complex
- Occasional repetition of key points
- Digital archive interfaces described as dated or difficult to navigate
Online ratings/reviews:
- Open Me Carefully: 4.6/5 on Amazon (32 reviews)
- Rowing in Eden: 4.3/5 on Goodreads (18 reviews)
- Digital projects receive positive mentions in academic reviews but fewer public ratings
Reader quote: "Smith's careful attention to manuscript evidence opens new ways of understanding Dickinson's writing process and relationships" - Amazon reviewer
📚 Similar books
Emily Dickinson's Poetry: Stairway of Surprise by Charles R. Anderson
This study reveals Dickinson's use of wit and wordplay through close readings of her poetic techniques and linguistic devices.
The Humor of the Old South by M. Thomas Inge and Edward J. Piacentino The examination of comic elements in 19th-century Southern literature provides context for understanding humor in American poetry of the same period.
Puns and Poetry in Lucretius' De Rerum Natura by Monica R. Gale This analysis of wordplay in classical poetry demonstrates how humor functions as a tool for expressing complex philosophical ideas.
Emily Dickinson: A Poet's Grammar by Cristanne Miller The book explores Dickinson's manipulation of language rules and grammatical structures to create layers of meaning and comic effect.
Comic Moments in American Literature by Robert Micklus This study traces the development of literary humor through key American texts from the colonial period through the nineteenth century.
The Humor of the Old South by M. Thomas Inge and Edward J. Piacentino The examination of comic elements in 19th-century Southern literature provides context for understanding humor in American poetry of the same period.
Puns and Poetry in Lucretius' De Rerum Natura by Monica R. Gale This analysis of wordplay in classical poetry demonstrates how humor functions as a tool for expressing complex philosophical ideas.
Emily Dickinson: A Poet's Grammar by Cristanne Miller The book explores Dickinson's manipulation of language rules and grammatical structures to create layers of meaning and comic effect.
Comic Moments in American Literature by Robert Micklus This study traces the development of literary humor through key American texts from the colonial period through the nineteenth century.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Martha Nell Smith co-founded the Dickinson Electronic Archives, one of the first digital humanities projects focused on a major American author
📚 The book explores how Dickinson used humor and wit as tools of empowerment, challenging the common perception of her as merely a reclusive, melancholy poet
✍️ Emily Dickinson created nearly 400 poems that could be categorized as comic or humorous, though this aspect of her work was long overlooked by scholars
🎨 Dickinson often included playful drawings and doodles alongside her poems in letters to friends, adding visual elements to her comic expression
📝 The manuscript study in this book reveals how Dickinson's unconventional punctuation and capitalization choices were often deliberate attempts at irony and wordplay