📖 Overview
Clean Straw for Nothing follows Australian journalist David Meredith who leaves his successful career behind to seek a new life on a Greek island. The story traces his physical and spiritual journey as he grapples with his decision to abandon conventional life in search of meaning.
The novel centers on Meredith's relationship with his wife Cressida as they attempt to build their new existence in Greece. Their marriage faces mounting pressures amid the challenges of expatriate life and Meredith's declining health.
The narrative moves between past and present, connecting Meredith's experiences in Greece with earlier periods of his life in Australia. His search for authenticity and purpose plays out against the backdrop of post-war social changes in both countries.
Johnston's semi-autobiographical work explores themes of escape, self-discovery, and the price of pursuing artistic and personal freedom. The novel questions whether geographic displacement can lead to spiritual fulfillment.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe Clean Straw for Nothing as a raw, autobiographical account that explores themes of exile and illness. The book appears less frequently reviewed compared to Johnston's My Brother Jack.
Readers praise:
- The honest portrayal of relationships and marriage
- The vivid descriptions of Greek island life
- The exploration of an artist's struggle with identity
- The complex emotional depth
Common criticisms:
- The narrative structure can be difficult to follow
- Some find the protagonist's self-pity excessive
- The pacing slows in the middle sections
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (based on 41 ratings)
Several readers note the book requires patience and multiple readings to fully appreciate. One reviewer stated: "The melancholy tone perfectly matches the protagonist's journey through illness and displacement."
Limited reviews exist on other platforms, making it challenging to gather a broad consensus of reader opinions.
📚 Similar books
My Brother Jack by David Meredith
A journalist navigates post-war Australian life while grappling with personal identity and familial expectations in Melbourne's middle-class suburbs.
The Tree of Man by Patrick White A man and woman build their life in rural Australia while confronting isolation, nature's challenges, and the search for meaning across decades.
Memoirs of Many in One by Patrick White The story follows an elderly woman's memories and delusions as she reflects on her past life in Australia and Europe through multiple personas.
The Last Thread by Michael Sala A migrant's journey between Naples and Australia reveals the complexities of displacement, family bonds, and cultural identity.
The Great World by David Malouf Two men's lives intersect through their experiences as POWs in World War II and their subsequent return to civilian life in Australia.
The Tree of Man by Patrick White A man and woman build their life in rural Australia while confronting isolation, nature's challenges, and the search for meaning across decades.
Memoirs of Many in One by Patrick White The story follows an elderly woman's memories and delusions as she reflects on her past life in Australia and Europe through multiple personas.
The Last Thread by Michael Sala A migrant's journey between Naples and Australia reveals the complexities of displacement, family bonds, and cultural identity.
The Great World by David Malouf Two men's lives intersect through their experiences as POWs in World War II and their subsequent return to civilian life in Australia.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Johnston wrote this novel while battling tuberculosis on the Greek island of Hydra, where he lived with his wife Charmian Clift and their children - paralleling the protagonist's journey.
🔹 The book won Australia's prestigious Miles Franklin Literary Award in 1970, cementing its place as a significant work in Australian literature.
🔹 The character of David Meredith was heavily influenced by Johnston's own experiences as a war correspondent during World War II before his escape to Greece.
🔹 Leonard Cohen was a close friend of Johnston and Clift during their time on Hydra, and the artistic community they fostered there influenced several of Cohen's early songs.
🔹 The novel forms part of a semi-autobiographical trilogy, with "My Brother Jack" (1964) and "Cartload of Clay" (1971) completing the series, though "Clean Straw for Nothing" is often considered the masterpiece of the three.