Which Witch?

A powerful wizard named Arriman the Awful must find a bride through a competition among the witches of Todcaster. The witch who performs the darkest magic will become his wife, fulfilling a prophecy about his successor. Among the contestants is Belladonna, a beautiful white witch who cannot perform dark magic but harbors deep feelings for Arriman. With help from a young orphan named Terence Mugg and his pet worm, she attempts to transform her abilities to compete in the contest. The stakes rise when Madame Olympia, a sinister witch with ulterior motives, enters the competition. The other witches' attempts at dark magic result in both comedic and dire consequences. This novel explores themes of authenticity and self-acceptance through a magical lens, challenging assumptions about good, evil, and the nature of true power.

Readers praise Which Witch? as a humorous children's fantasy focused on a dark wizard seeking a wife through a competition. Many reviews mention the book's dry humor and absurd situations that appeal to both children and adults. Readers liked: - Creative take on witch stereotypes - Character development of Belladonna - British humor and wordplay - Family-friendly despite dark themes Common criticisms: - Slower pacing in middle sections - Some dated cultural references - Character names can be confusing Ratings: Goodreads: 4.15/5 (13,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.6/5 (300+ ratings) One reader noted: "The wit reminds me of Roald Dahl but with more heart." Another mentioned: "Perfect for kids who find Harry Potter too intense." Several reviewers pointed out the book works well as a read-aloud, with parents enjoying it alongside children. Multiple readers recommended it for ages 8-12.

The House with Chicken Legs by Sophie Anderson A young witch who lives in a walking house with her grandmother discovers her destiny as she learns to guide spirits to the afterlife.

Howl's Moving Castle by Diana Wynne Jones A cursed girl enters the service of a mysterious wizard in his magical walking castle while trying to break her spell.

The Power of Poppy Pendle by Natasha Lowe A witch born with extraordinary magical powers pursues her passion for baking instead of spellcraft against her parents' wishes.

The Witches of Willow Cove by Josh Roberts Six teenage witches uncover secrets about their powers and their families while facing a centuries-old curse in their New England town.

The Witch's Boy by Kelly Barnhill A boy guards his mother's dangerous magic while forming an alliance with a bandit's daughter to prevent a war between kingdoms.

🌟 Eva Ibbotson fled to England from Vienna in 1934 to escape the Nazi regime, an experience that often influenced her writing's themes of displacement and finding home. 🌟 The character name "Arriman" is believed to be a play on "Harriman," meaning "ruler of the home" in Old English. 🌟 Todcaster, the book's setting, draws inspiration from traditional English market towns, particularly those in Yorkshire where Ibbotson spent much of her adult life. 🌟 The distinction between white and black magic in the book reflects medieval European folklore, where white witches were historically healers and herbalists who helped their communities. 🌟 Published in 1979, "Which Witch?" was one of Ibbotson's earliest children's novels, though she didn't begin writing for children until she was in her 50s.