📖 Overview
It Had to Be You chronicles the story of Phoebe Somerville, who inherits the Chicago Stars football team after her father's death. As a former beauty queen with a reputation for frivolity, she faces skepticism and resistance from the team's head coach Dan Calebow.
The novel centers on the complex dynamic between Phoebe and Dan as they navigate the high-stakes world of professional football. Their initial antagonism evolves while Phoebe works to prove herself as a capable team owner and Dan struggles to maintain control of his domain.
They each must confront their preconceptions and past experiences as circumstances force them to work together. The story features the inner workings of a professional football organization while exploring themes of family expectations and public perception.
The novel examines how people can transcend the labels others place on them and find authentic connections despite their differences. It considers the impact of family legacies and the courage required to forge one's own path.
👀 Reviews
Readers view this as a fun but emotionally complex romance with humor and depth. Many note it stands out in the sports romance genre.
Readers liked:
- The banter and chemistry between leads
- Character growth, especially Phoebe's transformation
- Balance of comedy and serious themes
- Football setting details
- Secondary characters and subplots
Common criticisms:
- Initial unlikeability of both main characters
- Some found early scenes too harsh/cruel
- Dated gender dynamics and attitudes
- Length (some say middle section drags)
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.15/5 (42,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.5/5 (800+ reviews)
BookBub: 4.4/5 (2,800+ ratings)
Representative review: "Started rough but evolved into something special. The hero and heroine's growth felt earned. Perfect mix of funny and emotional moments." - Goodreads reviewer
Several readers note this book improves on subsequent reads as the character arcs become more apparent.
📚 Similar books
Match Me If You Can by Jennifer Crusie
A sports agent inherits her father's agency and clashes with a rival agent while managing Chicago's top athletes.
Tangled by Emma Chase A ruthless investment banker's structured life unravels when he meets an interior designer who refuses to play by his rules.
The Hating Game by Sally Thorne Two executive assistants competing for the same promotion engage in office warfare that transforms into unexpected attraction.
Practice Makes Perfect by Julie James Two lawyers at a Chicago firm compete for the same partner position while their professional rivalry develops into romance.
Natural Born Charmer by Susan Elizabeth Phillips A NFL quarterback finds his life intersecting with a headstrong artist who challenges his views on relationships and success.
Tangled by Emma Chase A ruthless investment banker's structured life unravels when he meets an interior designer who refuses to play by his rules.
The Hating Game by Sally Thorne Two executive assistants competing for the same promotion engage in office warfare that transforms into unexpected attraction.
Practice Makes Perfect by Julie James Two lawyers at a Chicago firm compete for the same partner position while their professional rivalry develops into romance.
Natural Born Charmer by Susan Elizabeth Phillips A NFL quarterback finds his life intersecting with a headstrong artist who challenges his views on relationships and success.
🤔 Interesting facts
🏈 The Chicago Stars team featured in the book was inspired by the real-life Chicago Bears, with Phillips conducting extensive research into NFL operations and culture.
📚 This book kickstarted the seven-book Chicago Stars series, which became one of the most successful contemporary sports romance series of the 1990s.
🏆 "It Had to Be You" won the prestigious RITA Award in 1995 for Best Contemporary Single Title Romance, cementing Phillips' place in romance literature.
✍️ Susan Elizabeth Phillips was one of the first authors to successfully blend sports themes with contemporary romance, helping establish sports romance as a viable sub-genre.
💫 The author actually started her writing career collaborating with a neighbor on a novel, before launching her solo career with historical romances, making this contemporary sports romance a significant departure from her earlier work.