The Earth, My Butt, and Other Big Round Things

The Earth, My Butt, and Other Big Round Things follows Virginia Shreves, a fifteen-year-old struggling with body image issues and family expectations in Manhattan. Virginia attends a private high school where she feels like an outsider, especially compared to her high-achieving, conventionally attractive family members. The story tracks Virginia's relationship with Froggy Welsh the Fourth, her makeout buddy, while she navigates complex dynamics with her weight-obsessed mother, absent sister, and seemingly perfect brother Byron. When a serious incident at Columbia University forces Virginia to question everything she knows about her family, she begins a journey of self-discovery. Through kickboxing, fashion choices, and newfound assertiveness, Virginia starts making decisions for herself rather than trying to meet others' expectations. Her transformation involves both internal growth and external changes as she learns to define herself on her own terms. The novel tackles themes of body acceptance, family dynamics, and personal authenticity, presenting a realistic look at how teenagers navigate societal pressures and self-image. The story demonstrates how challenging family expectations can lead to personal empowerment.

Readers connect with the authentic portrayal of body image struggles and family dynamics. Many cite Virginia's voice as relatable and honest, particularly her internal dialogue about weight, dating, and parental expectations. Liked: - Raw, realistic depiction of teen insecurities - Complex family relationships - Character growth throughout story - Addresses serious topics without being preachy Disliked: - Some found the ending rushed - Parents' behavior can feel extreme - Fat-phobic language (though meant to show character perspective) - Romance subplot feels underdeveloped Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (37,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (500+ ratings) Sample review: "Finally a YA book that doesn't magically solve body image issues with a makeover. Virginia's struggle feels real." - Goodreads reviewer Another notes: "The casual use of fat-shaming language, even as internal dialogue, could be triggering for some readers." - Amazon reviewer

13 Little Blue Envelopes by Maureen Johnson A shy teen embarks on a European adventure through instructions left by her aunt, leading to self-discovery and independence from family expectations.

Holding Up the Universe by Jennifer Niven A teen girl faces judgment about her weight while developing an unexpected connection that changes her perspective on self-worth and acceptance.

Dumplin' by Julie Murphy A plus-size teenager enters a beauty pageant in her small Texas town, challenging beauty standards and her former beauty queen mother's expectations.

To All the Boys I've Loved Before by Jenny Han A private school student navigates family dynamics, romance, and finding her own voice while dealing with her sister's absence and cultural expectations.

What I Thought Was True by Huntley Fitzpatrick A working-class girl from a close-knit family confronts class differences, family pressures, and romance during a transformative summer.

🔹 The book won the prestigious Michael L. Printz Honor Award in 2004, recognizing excellence in young adult literature. 🔹 Originally published in 2003, the novel was ahead of its time in addressing body positivity and mental health issues in YA literature, leading to some initial controversy and censorship challenges. 🔹 The story was partially inspired by Mackler's own experiences growing up in Manhattan and attending private school, though she has stated Virginia's character is not directly autobiographical. 🔹 The book received a significant update in 2018 to include modern references to social media and current teen culture, while maintaining its core message about self-acceptance. 🔹 The novel's title comes from Virginia's personal list of "Fat Girl Rules," which she eventually learns to challenge and reject as part of her journey toward self-acceptance.