📖 Overview
A scientist-narrator in rural Austria encounters a Persian woman, the wife of a Swiss engineer. Their shared intellectual isolation draws them together for long walks in the forest, where they exchange extensive philosophical discussions.
The narrative centers on their developing connection through intense conversations and mutual understanding. The Persian woman and narrator are both wrestling with thoughts of suicide and existential despair, finding temporary solace in their cerebral companionship.
The novel is structured as a single block of text, following the narrator's stream of consciousness as he recounts these events to his friend Moritz. The story unfolds through memories, reflections, and lengthy philosophical monologues.
This is fundamentally a novel about isolation, confession, and the complex relationship between human connection and self-destruction. Through its stark Austrian setting and characteristic Bernhardian style, it explores how intellectual discourse can serve as both salvation and catalyst.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe Yes as intense, challenging monologue that requires focus and patience. Many note its circular, repetitive style creates a hypnotic effect.
Readers appreciate:
- The dark humor amidst despair
- The rhythmic, musical quality of the prose
- How it captures obsessive thought patterns
- The unflinching examination of human relationships
Common criticisms:
- Dense paragraphs and minimal punctuation make it hard to follow
- The repetition feels excessive to some
- Characters remain distant and abstract
- Some find the narrator's voice grating
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.1/5 (1,200+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (40+ ratings)
Notable reader comments:
"Like being trapped in someone else's anxiety spiral" -Goodreads reviewer
"The relentless repetition mirrors the characters' psychological states" -Amazon review
"Not for those seeking traditional plot or character development" -LibraryThing reviewer
📚 Similar books
The Rings of Saturn by W. G. Sebald
A melancholic narrator walks through East Anglia, weaving together histories, memories, and philosophical meditations in one continuous narrative flow.
The Notebooks of Malte Laurids Brigge by Rainer Maria Rilke A solitary young Danish writer in Paris records his observations and existential reflections in a series of fragmented journal entries.
The Loser by Thomas Bernhard Three pianists pursue artistic perfection while grappling with failure and suicide in the Austrian countryside.
Concrete by Thomas Bernhard A musicologist in Vienna postpones writing his study on Mendelssohn while spiraling through memories and philosophical digressions.
Walking by Thomas Tuma A man takes daily walks through Budapest while contemplating art, death, and failure in an unbroken stream of consciousness.
The Notebooks of Malte Laurids Brigge by Rainer Maria Rilke A solitary young Danish writer in Paris records his observations and existential reflections in a series of fragmented journal entries.
The Loser by Thomas Bernhard Three pianists pursue artistic perfection while grappling with failure and suicide in the Austrian countryside.
Concrete by Thomas Bernhard A musicologist in Vienna postpones writing his study on Mendelssohn while spiraling through memories and philosophical digressions.
Walking by Thomas Tuma A man takes daily walks through Budapest while contemplating art, death, and failure in an unbroken stream of consciousness.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Thomas Bernhard wrote "Yes" in 1978 while recovering from a severe respiratory illness, infusing the work with themes of physical and emotional isolation that mirrored his own experiences.
🔹 The novel's unique structure of long, unbroken paragraphs and repetitive phrases was revolutionary in Austrian literature and influenced a generation of experimental writers.
🔹 The character of the Persian woman was inspired by a real encounter Bernhard had with an Iranian student during his walks in the Austrian countryside near his home in Ohlsdorf.
🔹 The book's German title "Ja" (Yes) serves as an ironic counterpoint to Bernhard's earlier work "No" ("Nein"), creating a philosophical dialogue between affirmation and negation across his bibliography.
🔹 The forest walks depicted in the novel take place in the Salzkammergut region of Austria, an area known for its dramatic Alpine landscapes and connection to numerous artistic and intellectual figures, including Gustav Klimt and Sigmund Freud.