📖 Overview
Incidents is a collection of four essays published posthumously in 1987, containing some of Roland Barthes' most personal writing. The book includes reflections on the South West of France, observations from a trip to Morocco, descriptions of a Parisian theater, and diary entries from 1979.
Each piece presents a different facet of Barthes' experiences and observations. The essays range from meditations on place and memory to frank accounts of personal relationships and encounters, written in Barthes' characteristic analytical style.
The collection moves between various locations - from rural France to North Africa to Paris - while maintaining an intimate perspective throughout. These works were written between 1969 and 1979, representing different periods in Barthes' life and career.
The essays represent a departure from Barthes' academic writing, offering instead a more personal mode of expression that connects to larger themes of identity, desire, and the relationship between private experience and public spaces.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this collection of Barthes' brief observations as fragmentary and intimate. The short entries function as both philosophical musings and personal diary entries.
Positive reviews highlight:
- Raw, unfiltered thoughts that feel immediate
- Glimpses into Barthes' daily life and mind
- The open-ended, poetic style
- Value for writers seeking inspiration
Common criticisms:
- Too scattered and disconnected
- Lacks the rigor of his academic work
- Can feel pretentious or self-indulgent
- Some entries are cryptic without context
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.0/5 (483 ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (21 ratings)
"Like reading someone's private notes that weren't meant for publication," wrote one Goodreads reviewer. Another noted: "Beautiful fragments that capture fleeting moments of insight."
Several readers compared it to diary entries or poetry rather than traditional philosophy, with one Amazon review stating "Don't expect structured arguments - this is Barthes at his most personal and experimental."
📚 Similar books
A Lover's Discourse by Roland Barthes
The fragmentary exploration of love and desire mirrors Incidents' personal revelations through similar analytical yet intimate prose.
Mourning Diary by Roland Barthes These diary entries following the death of Barthes' mother share the same unguarded personal writing found in Incidents.
Camera Lucida by Susan Sontag Sontag's meditations on photography and memory employ the same blend of theory and personal experience present in Incidents.
The Practice of Everyday Life by Michel de Certeau De Certeau examines daily life and urban spaces through a theoretical lens that parallels Barthes' observations of place and culture.
Morocco by Paul Bowles Bowles' accounts of Morocco combine travel observations and personal encounters in ways that echo Barthes' own Moroccan writings in Incidents.
Mourning Diary by Roland Barthes These diary entries following the death of Barthes' mother share the same unguarded personal writing found in Incidents.
Camera Lucida by Susan Sontag Sontag's meditations on photography and memory employ the same blend of theory and personal experience present in Incidents.
The Practice of Everyday Life by Michel de Certeau De Certeau examines daily life and urban spaces through a theoretical lens that parallels Barthes' observations of place and culture.
Morocco by Paul Bowles Bowles' accounts of Morocco combine travel observations and personal encounters in ways that echo Barthes' own Moroccan writings in Incidents.
🤔 Interesting facts
⚡ Barthes met his untimely death in 1980 after being struck by a laundry van while walking home from lunch with François Mitterrand, who would later become the President of France.
🖋️ Despite being known primarily as a literary theorist, Barthes was an accomplished pianist who often drew parallels between musical interpretation and textual analysis in his work.
📝 The essays in "Incidents" were discovered among Barthes' personal papers after his death and were not originally intended for publication, leading to ethical debates about private versus public writings.
🌍 The Moroccan sections of "Incidents" were written during Barthes' time teaching in Rabat in 1969, and they contain subtle observations about colonialism and cultural dynamics in post-colonial North Africa.
📚 This collection marked a significant shift in Barthes' writing style, moving from his earlier structured academic works (like "Mythologies") to a more intimate, fragmentary form that influenced modern autobiographical writing.