📖 Overview
Laura Thornby, a 45-year-old single woman known for interfering in others' lives, meets 23-year-old Claud Bannister at a concert. After learning of his failed accounting exams and writing aspirations, she takes immediate interest in redirecting his path.
Laura helps Claud establish himself in a rented loft and set up an antique stall at the local market, creating space for him to pursue his writing. Their relationship evolves beyond mentorship into a physical affair, marking a departure from Laura's typically controlled romantic encounters.
As Claud develops his novel and finds his footing in his new life, Laura begins to experience an unfamiliar loss of control. Their age difference, the London arts scene, and the complex web of relationships surrounding them create mounting tensions.
The novel explores themes of control versus creativity, the price of independence, and the unexpected ways people influence each other's lives. Through the lens of an unconventional relationship, Second Fiddle examines how artists find their voice and how the roles of mentor and muse can shift in surprising ways.
👀 Reviews
Readers often describe Second Fiddle as a darkly humorous take on family relationships and English society, though many find it less engaging than Wesley's other novels.
Readers appreciated:
- Sharp observations of marriage and social class
- The complex mother-daughter dynamics
- Wesley's dry wit and dialogue
- The portrayal of post-war British society
Common criticisms:
- Slower pacing than Wesley's other books
- Too many characters to follow
- Lack of sympathetic characters
- Confusing timeline shifts
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.5/5 (102 ratings)
Amazon UK: 3.7/5 (24 reviews)
One reader noted: "The characters are all horrible people, but that's rather the point." Another commented: "Not as compelling as The Camomile Lawn, but Wesley's keen eye for human nature shines through."
Multiple reviewers mentioned struggling to finish the book, with several abandoning it partway through due to the meandering plot.
📚 Similar books
Lady Chatterley's Lover by D. H. Lawrence
An older woman and younger man navigate passion and class boundaries in the English countryside while challenging social conventions.
The Lover by Marguerite Duras Set in colonial French Indochina, a teenage girl enters a transformative relationship with an older Chinese man who supports her artistic development.
Mrs. Palfrey at the Claremont by Elizabeth Taylor An aging woman forms an unexpected friendship with a young writer in London, leading to mutual growth and understanding.
The Hours by Michael Cunningham Three women's lives intertwine across different time periods through their connection to literature and creative expression.
The Piano Teacher by Elfriede Jelinek A music teacher's controlled existence unravels when she begins an intense relationship with a younger student in Vienna's artistic circles.
The Lover by Marguerite Duras Set in colonial French Indochina, a teenage girl enters a transformative relationship with an older Chinese man who supports her artistic development.
Mrs. Palfrey at the Claremont by Elizabeth Taylor An aging woman forms an unexpected friendship with a young writer in London, leading to mutual growth and understanding.
The Hours by Michael Cunningham Three women's lives intertwine across different time periods through their connection to literature and creative expression.
The Piano Teacher by Elfriede Jelinek A music teacher's controlled existence unravels when she begins an intense relationship with a younger student in Vienna's artistic circles.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔸 Mary Wesley didn't publish her first adult novel until age 71, going on to become a bestselling author in her seventies and eighties.
🔸 The novel's London market scenes were inspired by Portobello Road Market, one of the world's largest antique markets, established in the 1800s.
🔸 Wesley drew from personal experience in depicting May-December romances; she had several relationships with younger men throughout her life.
🔸 The book was published in 1988, during a period when age-gap relationships in British literature were rarely portrayed from the older woman's perspective.
🔸 The character of Laura Thornby appears as a minor character in two other Wesley novels, creating an interconnected universe within her work.