Book

Emma in Winter

📖 Overview

Emma in Winter follows Emma Makepeace during her time at a village school in the South Downs of England. The young girl lives with her sister Charlotte at their grandfather's house, Aviary Hall, and must navigate the challenges of growing up without parents. Emma faces various struggles at her small rural school, where she deals with social dynamics among her classmates and grapples with her own place in the world. Her relationship with her more responsible sister Charlotte forms a central part of her journey through the winter months. The book is part of a trilogy known as the Aviary Hall series, serving as a bridge between The Summer Birds and Charlotte Sometimes. Set in the 1960s, it captures the atmosphere of post-war British countryside life and the particular experiences of children in that era. The novel explores themes of identity, sisterhood, and the complex transition from childhood to adolescence. Through Emma's experiences, the story examines how young people cope with loss and find their own path to maturity.

👀 Reviews

Readers consistently note Emma in Winter's dream-like, surreal atmosphere. Many found the haunting tone and psychological elements make it a worthy sequel to Charlotte Sometimes. Positive reviews highlight: - Vivid descriptions of winter landscapes - Complex handling of grief and isolation themes - Compelling parallel between Emma's physical and emotional journey - Memorable supporting characters, especially Alicia Common criticisms: - Slower pacing than Charlotte Sometimes - More abstract/less accessible plot - Some found the ending unsatisfying Ratings: Goodreads: 3.8/5 (54 ratings) Amazon: Out of print, limited reviews available From reviews: "The winter setting becomes almost a character itself" - Goodreads reviewer "Beautiful but requires patience" - LibraryThing user "Not as immediately gripping as Charlotte Sometimes, but rewards careful reading" - Vintage Children's Books blog "The dream sequences can be confusing but create a unique atmosphere" - Children's Literature review

📚 Similar books

Tom's Midnight Garden by Philippa Pearce Time-shifting tale of a lonely child in England who discovers a mysterious garden that connects them to the past.

The Children of Green Knowe by Lucy M. Boston A young boy moves to an old English manor house where he encounters the spirits of children who lived there centuries before.

Carrie's War by Nina Bawden Set during WWII evacuation, this story follows a girl sent to live in the Welsh countryside as she navigates new relationships and family dynamics.

The House in Norham Gardens by Penelope Lively A teenage girl living with elderly relatives in Oxford confronts family history and growing up in a historic house.

A String in the Harp by Nancy Bond Set in Wales, this story follows children coping with their mother's death while living with their father in a rural setting where past and present intersect.

🤔 Interesting facts

🔸 Penelope Farmer wrote several acclaimed children's books in the 1960s-70s, including the celebrated "Charlotte Sometimes" which inspired a song of the same name by The Cure. 🔸 The South Downs, where the story is set, is a range of chalk hills extending over 260 square miles across southern England, designated as a National Park in 2010. 🔸 The book is part of a trilogy featuring the Makepeace sisters, with "Charlotte Sometimes" being the most famous installment, exploring themes of time travel and identity. 🔸 Aviary Hall, the family home in the story, reflects a common feature of English country houses where aviaries were fashionable additions during the Victorian era. 🔸 The novel's 1960s publication coincided with a golden age of British children's literature, alongside works by authors like Mary Norton and Lucy M. Boston, who similarly blended realism with subtle fantasy elements.