📖 Overview
Sherlock Holmes: The Breath of God brings Holmes and Watson face to face with seemingly supernatural deaths that challenge their rational worldview. The investigation leads them to cross paths with real historical figure Aleister Crowley and fictional occult detective Thomas Carnacki.
The novel pits Holmes's famous deductive methods against elements of the paranormal and occult. Set against the backdrop of Victorian London, the story tests the limits of logic and reason as the detectives pursue answers to inexplicable events.
Traditional Holmes case elements blend with supernatural horror, creating a mystery that bridges multiple genres. The book stays true to Arthur Conan Doyle's established characters while introducing them to new territory through their encounters with the paranormal.
The novel explores themes of rationality versus faith, and questions what happens when a purely logical mind confronts apparently supernatural phenomena. Through this lens, it examines the nature of truth and the boundaries between the explainable and inexplicable.
👀 Reviews
Readers found this Holmes pastiche struggled to capture Doyle's style, with many noting it veered too far into supernatural territory. The book holds a 3.4/5 rating on Goodreads from 280+ ratings.
Readers appreciated:
- Fast-paced action sequences
- Integration of historical figures like Aleister Crowley
- Atmosphere and Victorian horror elements
Common criticisms:
- Holmes acts out of character
- Writing style differs significantly from canonical Holmes
- Plot relies too heavily on supernatural elements
- Resolution feels rushed and unsatisfying
"The supernatural aspects overwhelm the detective work that makes Holmes stories great," noted one Amazon reviewer. Several Goodreads reviews mentioned the dialogue felt modern rather than period-appropriate.
Ratings:
Amazon: 3.8/5 (50+ reviews)
Goodreads: 3.4/5 (280+ reviews)
LibraryThing: 3.3/5 (25+ reviews)
Most recommended for horror fans rather than Holmes purists.
📚 Similar books
Anno Dracula by Kim Newman
Victorian literary characters, including Sherlock Holmes's companions, intersect with vampires in an alternate history where Dracula rules England.
The List of Seven by Mark Frost A writer teams up with a mysterious investigator to uncover occult conspiracies in Victorian London while facing supernatural threats.
The Somnambulist by Jonathan Barnes A Victorian-era magician and detective confronts dark occult forces in London while investigating a series of impossible crimes.
The Shadow Over Baker Street by Michael Reaves This collection merges Sherlock Holmes cases with H.P. Lovecraft's cosmic horror in Victorian London.
The Haunting of Alaizabel Cray by Chris Wooding A wych-hunter in an alternate Victorian London investigates supernatural cases while uncovering a dark conspiracy involving ancient entities.
The List of Seven by Mark Frost A writer teams up with a mysterious investigator to uncover occult conspiracies in Victorian London while facing supernatural threats.
The Somnambulist by Jonathan Barnes A Victorian-era magician and detective confronts dark occult forces in London while investigating a series of impossible crimes.
The Shadow Over Baker Street by Michael Reaves This collection merges Sherlock Holmes cases with H.P. Lovecraft's cosmic horror in Victorian London.
The Haunting of Alaizabel Cray by Chris Wooding A wych-hunter in an alternate Victorian London investigates supernatural cases while uncovering a dark conspiracy involving ancient entities.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔍 Aleister Crowley, who appears as a character in the book, was nicknamed "The Wickedest Man in the World" by the British press and founded his own religious philosophy called Thelema.
🎭 Thomas Carnacki, another character featured in the novel, was originally created by author William Hope Hodgson in 1910 and was one of literature's first "occult detectives."
🌫️ Victorian London's infamous fog, which provides the atmospheric backdrop for the novel, was actually toxic "pea-soup" smog caused by coal burning and claimed thousands of lives.
✒️ Guy Adams, before becoming an author, worked as a professional actor and theatrical agent, bringing a natural sense of drama to his writing.
📚 The novel is part of a growing subgenre called "Holmes pastiche," which consists of Sherlock Holmes stories written by authors other than Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, with over 25,000 such works published since Holmes's creation.