The Life of Mary Baker G. Eddy and the History of Christian Science

The Life of Mary Baker G. Eddy and the History of Christian Science (1909) examines the founder of Christian Science and her religious movement in 19th-century New England. The work represents one of the first comprehensive studies of Eddy's life and the early Christian Science church. Originally published as a series in McClure's magazine between 1907 and 1908, the text was later compiled into a 566-page book by Doubleday, Page & Company. The authorship has been debated, with initial attribution to journalist Georgine Milmine and later recognition of novelist Willa Cather's significant editorial contributions. The book chronicles Eddy's personal history and the development of Christian Science through extensive research and contemporary accounts. The narrative tracks the movement's growth from its New England origins to its establishment as a formal religious organization. The text stands as a significant historical document that explores themes of religious innovation, leadership, and the intersection of spirituality and medicine in American society. The work raises questions about the nature of religious authority and the relationship between faith and healing.

Readers find this biography thorough and well-researched, drawing heavily from newspaper archives and firsthand accounts. Many note that Cather's involvement adds literary polish to the investigative reporting. Readers praise: - Detailed documentation of Eddy's early life and influences - Balanced examination of her medical history - Clear explanation of Christian Science's development - Inclusion of rare source materials and interviews Common criticisms: - Writing can be dry in sections focused on legal matters - Some readers feel the tone is too critical of Eddy - Christian Science followers dispute certain characterizations Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (126 ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 (31 ratings) Reader quote: "The most complete and objective biography of Mary Baker Eddy available. While Christian Scientists may disagree with some conclusions, the research and documentation are impeccable." - Goodreads reviewer The book remains the primary critical biography of Eddy, though Christian Science followers prefer authorized church biographies.

God's Perfect Child: Living and Dying in the Christian Science Church by Caroline Fraser The text documents the evolution and impact of Christian Science through archival records and first-person accounts from former members.

Religious Outsiders and the Making of Americans by R. Laurence Moore This study examines how marginalized religious movements like Christian Science shaped American religious identity.

Each Mind a Kingdom: American Women, Sexual Purity, and the New Thought Movement by Beryl Satter The book explores the connection between nineteenth-century women's religious leadership and the New Thought movement.

Mesmerism and the American Cure of Souls by Robert Fuller The text traces the development of mind-cure movements in nineteenth-century America and their influence on religious practices.

The Church of Christ, Scientist: Its History, Teachings, and Legal Development by Norman Beasley This work presents the institutional development of Christian Science through legal documents and organizational records.

🔍 The serialization in McClure's magazine took nearly two years (1907-1908), making it one of the most extensive investigative pieces of its era. 📚 Willa Cather, who contributed to the book's editing, later became a Pulitzer Prize-winning novelist known for works like "O Pioneers!" and "My Ántonia." ⚕️ Mary Baker Eddy was 87 when this biography was published and actively fought against its release, considering it an unauthorized account of her life. 🏛️ The research team collected over 100,000 words worth of sworn affidavits and statements from people who knew Mary Baker Eddy personally. 🗞️ The book caused such controversy that many copies were allegedly bought and destroyed by Christian Science adherents, making original editions particularly rare today.