The Long Secret

The Long Secret is a 1965 children's novel by Louise Fitzhugh, serving as a sequel to the acclaimed Harriet the Spy. Set during summer in Water Mill, Long Island, the story follows returning character Harriet and her friend Beth Ellen "Mouse" Hanson. The plot centers on mysterious religious-themed notes appearing around town, revealing people's private misdeeds. Harriet takes on the role of detective while involving her reluctant friend Beth Ellen in surveillance activities targeting various town residents. The narrative explores Beth Ellen's complex family dynamics when her long-absent mother returns from Europe with a new husband. This development forces Beth Ellen to confront changes in her previously stable life with her grandmother. The Long Secret examines themes of identity, family relationships, and the transition from childhood to adolescence. The story balances its mystery elements with a deeper exploration of personal growth and self-discovery.

Readers note this sequel to Harriet the Spy focuses more on Beth Ellen, with many finding it a more complex and nuanced book than its predecessor. The slower pace and psychological elements resonate with adult readers more than children. Readers appreciate: - The realistic portrayal of mother-daughter relationships - The honest handling of religious themes and puberty - Beth Ellen's character development - The Hamptons summer setting Common criticisms: - Less engaging than Harriet the Spy - Too mature/complex for younger readers - Slower plot with less action - Harriet appears less frequently than expected Ratings: Goodreads: 3.8/5 (2,100+ ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 (50+ ratings) "A thoughtful book about growing up that rewards rereading as an adult," notes one Goodreads reviewer. Another adds: "The themes are sophisticated but important for young readers." Several reviewers mention being disappointed as children but appreciating the book more upon reading it as adults.

Caddie Woodlawn by Carol Ryrie Brink This historical fiction follows a spirited 11-year-old girl in Wisconsin frontier life who questions societal expectations and navigates friendship and family relationships.

When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead A mystery unfolds in 1970s New York City as sixth-grader Miranda receives cryptic notes and works to understand changes in her friendships and identity.

From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler by E. L. Konigsburg Two siblings run away to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City and become entangled in an art mystery while discovering truths about themselves.

The View from Saturday by E. L. Konigsburg Four sixth-grade students form an unlikely quiz bowl team while uncovering connections in their lives and confronting questions of belonging and identity.

Up a Road Slowly by Irene Hunt A young girl moves to live with her aunt in rural Illinois and experiences growth through relationships, loss, and self-discovery from age seven to seventeen.

🔍 "The Long Secret" was published in 1965, a year after the massively successful "Harriet the Spy," making it one of the first YA sequels to feature a female protagonist. 🌊 Water Mill, where the story is set, is a real Hampton community established in 1644 and is home to one of the few remaining working water mills from that era. 📝 Unlike "Harriet the Spy," this book shifts focus to Beth Ellen as the central character, marking one of the earliest examples in children's literature of a sequel spotlighting a secondary character. 👥 Louise Fitzhugh broke new ground by addressing topics like menstruation and religious hypocrisy in children's literature, subjects that were largely taboo in 1960s youth fiction. 🎨 Before becoming an author, Fitzhugh was a professional artist who studied at the Art Students League in New York and illustrated all her own books, including the original drawings for "The Long Secret."