📖 Overview
Island of Silence follows the magical realm of Artimé as it faces new threats from mysterious arrivals and opposing forces. The second installment in The Unwanteds series continues the story of Alex Stowe and his fellow creative teenagers who have found sanctuary in this hidden world.
Alex begins training as a head mage under Mr. Today's guidance while tensions escalate between Artimé and the stark society of Quill. The arrival of two silent strangers with orange eyes signals the beginning of mounting dangers that will test the strength and unity of Artimé's inhabitants.
A rescue mission leads Alex and his companions to discover dark truths about neighboring islands and forces them to confront enemies both familiar and unknown. The story builds on the magical system established in the first book while expanding the scope of the world beyond Artimé's borders.
The novel explores themes of leadership, sacrifice, and the price of power through its young characters who must step into roles they never expected to fill. Their struggle to protect their creative haven against those who would destroy it reflects broader conflicts between artistic freedom and rigid control.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe Island of Silence as a darker and more intense follow-up to The Unwanteds, with higher stakes and deeper character development. The pacing builds tension throughout, though some note it moves slower than book one.
Readers liked:
- Character growth, especially Alex's leadership journey
- More complex moral dilemmas
- World-building details about Artime and Quill
- The emotional depth of relationships between characters
Common criticisms:
- Cliffhanger ending frustrated many young readers
- Some found the silence premise hard to follow
- Middle section pacing drags for some readers
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.3/5 (16,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.7/5 (380+ ratings)
"The stakes feel much higher and more personal," noted one Goodreads reviewer. Another mentioned: "My kids couldn't put it down but the ending made them anxious for the next book."
Several parents appreciated the themes of sacrifice and responsibility, though some felt certain scenes were too intense for younger readers.
📚 Similar books
The Unwanteds by Alex Gutman
Children with magical abilities face trials in a hidden world where creativity equals power.
The School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani Two friends navigate a magical academy that trains students to become fairy tale heroes or villains.
The Keeper of the Lost Cities by Shannon Messenger A girl discovers her telepathic powers and enters a secret society of beings with extraordinary abilities.
The Land of Stories by Chris Colfer Twins fall into a world where fairy tales exist and must navigate through magical realms to return home.
Septimus Heap: Magyk by Angie Sage A boy learns he possesses extraordinary magical powers while uncovering secrets about his true identity in a world of wizards and ancient prophecies.
The School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani Two friends navigate a magical academy that trains students to become fairy tale heroes or villains.
The Keeper of the Lost Cities by Shannon Messenger A girl discovers her telepathic powers and enters a secret society of beings with extraordinary abilities.
The Land of Stories by Chris Colfer Twins fall into a world where fairy tales exist and must navigate through magical realms to return home.
Septimus Heap: Magyk by Angie Sage A boy learns he possesses extraordinary magical powers while uncovering secrets about his true identity in a world of wizards and ancient prophecies.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Lisa McMann wrote her first novel at age 14, though it was never published
🌟 The Unwanteds series (of which Island of Silence is Book 2) has been described by Kirkus Reviews as "The Hunger Games meets Harry Potter"
🌟 The orange-eyed characters in Island of Silence were inspired by McMann's fascination with unusual genetic traits in humans
🌟 The magical world of Artimé was partially influenced by McMann's childhood experiences of creating imaginary worlds in her backyard
🌟 Before becoming a full-time author, McMann worked as a waitress, receptionist, and middle school teacher, which helped shape her understanding of young readers