📖 Overview
Modern Classics of Fantasy is a comprehensive anthology of fantasy short works spanning from the 1930s to the 1990s, edited by renowned editor Gardner Dozois.
The collection features 32 stories from acclaimed authors including Ursula K. Le Guin, Fritz Leiber, Gene Wolfe, and Jack Vance. Each story represents significant developments in fantasy literature across several decades of publishing.
The anthology covers a broad spectrum of fantasy subgenres, from traditional sword and sorcery to contemporary magical realism. Works range in length from short stories to novellas, providing readers with varied storytelling formats.
The collection demonstrates the evolution and versatility of fantasy literature, showing how the genre has adapted to changing literary tastes while maintaining its core elements of imagination and wonder.
👀 Reviews
Readers value this anthology for collecting influential fantasy stories from 1950-1990 in one volume. Many comment on the balance between familiar names (Le Guin, King) and lesser-known authors they discovered through the collection.
Positives from reviews:
- Strong editorial selection showing fantasy's evolution
- Inclusion of hard-to-find stories no longer in print
- Detailed author introductions provide context
- Mix of humor, horror, and literary styles
Common criticisms:
- Some stories feel dated or slow-paced
- Too much emphasis on literary/experimental works
- Length (over 600 pages) makes it unwieldy
- Exclusion of certain major authors
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.0/5 (219 ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (11 reviews)
Multiple reviewers specifically praise the inclusion of Sturgeon's "The Silken-Swift" and Powers' "Down and Out in Purgatory." Several note that the academic tone of Dozois' introductions can be dry but informative.
📚 Similar books
The Big Book of Modern Fantasy by Ann VanderMeer, Jeff VanderMeer
This collection spans 1945-2010 and features many of the same influential fantasy authors included in Dozois' anthology.
Masterpieces: The Best Science Fiction of the Century by Orson Scott Card The science fiction companion piece to Dozois' fantasy collection presents genre-defining stories from the 20th century.
The Dark Descent by David G. Hartwell This compilation traces horror fiction's evolution through carefully selected stories that intersect with fantasy literature's darker elements.
The Secret History of Fantasy by Peter S. Beagle The collection challenges traditional fantasy boundaries with stories that expand beyond conventional sword-and-sorcery narratives.
Legends: Short Novels by the Masters of Modern Fantasy by Robert Silverberg This anthology features novellas from established fantasy authors who appear in Dozois' collection and similarly shaped the genre.
Masterpieces: The Best Science Fiction of the Century by Orson Scott Card The science fiction companion piece to Dozois' fantasy collection presents genre-defining stories from the 20th century.
The Dark Descent by David G. Hartwell This compilation traces horror fiction's evolution through carefully selected stories that intersect with fantasy literature's darker elements.
The Secret History of Fantasy by Peter S. Beagle The collection challenges traditional fantasy boundaries with stories that expand beyond conventional sword-and-sorcery narratives.
Legends: Short Novels by the Masters of Modern Fantasy by Robert Silverberg This anthology features novellas from established fantasy authors who appear in Dozois' collection and similarly shaped the genre.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Gardner Dozois edited The Year's Best Science Fiction series for an astounding 35 consecutive years (1984-2018), earning him widespread recognition as one of science fiction's most influential editors.
🏆 He won 15 Hugo Awards for Best Professional Editor, making him one of the most decorated editors in the genre's history.
📚 Beyond editing, Dozois was an accomplished author who won two Nebula Awards for his own short fiction, demonstrating his mastery of both writing and curating speculative fiction.
🔮 The term "fantasy" as a distinct literary genre didn't gain widespread recognition until the 1920s-30s, coinciding with the earliest stories included in this anthology.
📖 Several stories in this collection first appeared in the Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, which has been continuously published since 1949, making it the second-longest-running science fiction magazine in history.