Book

The Animal That Therefore I Am

📖 Overview

The Animal That Therefore I Am presents philosopher Jacques Derrida's examination of human-animal relationships, based on his 1997 address at the Cerisy Conference. The work explores fundamental questions about animal consciousness, human exceptionalism, and the ethical implications of how humans treat other species. The book combines Derrida's original ten-hour lecture with several related essays from the conference, including "And Say The Animal Responded." His analysis begins with a personal encounter with his cat and expands into a broader philosophical investigation of how humans have historically defined themselves in relation to animals. This text became a cornerstone of Animal Studies in literary criticism and critical theory, though Derrida noted that animals had been a focus throughout his career. Through precise philosophical arguments and careful textual analysis, Derrida challenges traditional Western philosophical assumptions about the divide between humans and other animals. The work contributes to ongoing debates about animal consciousness, ethics, and the nature of being, while questioning fundamental assumptions about human supremacy and rationality. These investigations remain relevant to contemporary discussions of animal rights, environmental ethics, and human-animal relationships.

👀 Reviews

Readers note this text offers deep philosophical examination of human-animal relationships, though many find Derrida's writing style challenging to follow. Positive reviews highlight: - Fresh perspective on animal consciousness and ethics - Thoughtful analysis of how humans view themselves in relation to animals - Compelling observations about his cat watching him naked Common criticisms: - Dense, circular writing that obscures key points - Overuse of complex terminology - Lack of clear structure and conclusions - Translation issues in English version Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 4.1/5 (246 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (21 ratings) Several academic readers mention using specific chapters rather than the complete text. One reviewer on Goodreads notes: "Important ideas buried in unnecessarily complex prose." An Amazon reviewer states: "Worth pushing through the difficult passages for the insights on human-animal dynamics."

📚 Similar books

On Animals by Susan Orlean Chronicles diverse human-animal relationships across cultures and contexts, examining how these connections shape both human society and animal lives.

Zoopolis: A Political Theory of Animal Rights by Will Kymlicka, Sue Donaldson Presents a new framework for understanding human obligations to animals through the lens of political theory and citizenship.

The Great Ape Project by Paola Cavalieri Collects essays from scholars and scientists making the case for extending basic rights to great apes based on cognitive and emotional capabilities.

How Forests Think by Eduardo Kohn Explores how living beings beyond humans perceive and interact with their world through an anthropological study of human-animal relations in Ecuador's Amazon region.

The Others: How Animals Made Us Human by Paul Shepard Traces the evolutionary and psychological importance of animals in human development and consciousness through anthropological and biological perspectives.

🤔 Interesting facts

🐾 The cat that inspired this philosophical work was Derrida's own pet, whom he named "Logos" - a deliberate play on the Greek word for logic and reason. 🎓 Derrida coined the term "carnophallogocentrism" in this work to describe how Western culture privileges meat-eating, masculine authority, and rational thought. 📚 The book's French title "L'animal que donc je suis" is a clever wordplay - "suis" can mean both "I am" and "I follow," creating multiple layers of meaning about human-animal relationships. 🗣️ The original 10-hour lecture at Cerisy was delivered while Derrida was completely naked, mirroring his description of being seen naked by his cat - a controversial moment that became central to the work's examination of vulnerability and shame. 🌟 Published posthumously in 2006, two years after Derrida's death, the book has influenced diverse fields including philosophy, animal rights activism, environmental ethics, and posthumanist studies.