The Fifth Petal

A brutal murder in present-day Salem brings police chief John Rafferty face-to-face with an unsolved case from 1989 known as the Goddess Murders. The investigation forces the town to confront its dark history, as the new death mirrors the earlier killings of three women descended from Salem Witch Trial victims. Rose Whelan, once a respected historian and now a mentally unstable homeless woman, holds the key to both past and present mysteries. Callie Cahill, the daughter of one of the original victims, returns to Salem to uncover the truth about her mother's death and finds herself drawn into the investigation. The story combines elements of police procedural, supernatural occurrence, and historical research as multiple characters work to untangle the connections between modern Salem and its infamous witch trial past. The investigation reveals hidden family ties, ancient healing practices, and long-buried secrets within the community. The Fifth Petal examines themes of justice, redemption, and the ways traumatic events echo through generations. The novel raises questions about how communities remember their histories and what responsibilities the present owes to the past.

Readers found this Salem-set mystery engaging but slower-paced than Barry's previous work. Many noted the complex layering of past and present storylines, with some struggling to follow the multiple timelines and large cast of characters. Readers appreciated: - Historical details about Salem and witch trials - Character development of Callie and Rose - Integration of supernatural elements with police procedural - Exploration of trauma and healing Common criticisms: - Plot moves too slowly in first third - Too many subplots and characters to track - Some historical sections feel like textbook excerpts - Uneven pacing Ratings: Goodreads: 3.7/5 (3,800+ ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (450+ ratings) LibraryThing: 3.8/5 (150+ ratings) Reader quote: "The mystery kept me guessing, but the numerous plot threads made it hard to stay invested." - Goodreads reviewer

The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane by Katherine Howe A Harvard graduate student discovers her family's connection to the Salem Witch Trials while researching colonial-era healing practices and confronting unexplained events in present-day Massachusetts.

The Guest List by Lucy Foley A murder at an isolated wedding forces investigators to untangle connections between guests, revealing generational secrets and long-buried crimes from the past.

The Bone Maker by Sarah Beth Durst Twenty-five years after solving a series of ritual murders, a bone magic practitioner must confront the return of an ancient evil and face unresolved trauma from her past.

The Death of Mrs. Westaway by Ruth Ware A woman receives a mysterious inheritance connected to dark family secrets, leading her to uncover decades-old murders while navigating dangerous present-day circumstances.

The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie by Alan Bradley An eleven-year-old aspiring chemist investigates a murder on her family estate, uncovering connections between present crimes and historical events from the 1940s.

🌟 Salem's last accused witch, Giles Corey, was pressed to death with stones in 1692 - a cruel execution method that appears as a significant historical reference in the novel. 🌟 Author Brunonia Barry lives in Salem, Massachusetts, and conducts extensive research in local archives to ensure historical accuracy in her novels. 🌟 The "Fifth Petal" refers to the pentacle symbol, where each point represents an element (earth, air, fire, water), with the fifth point symbolizing spirit or consciousness. 🌟 The book's release in 2017 coincided with the 325th anniversary of the Salem Witch Trials, adding another layer of historical significance to its narrative. 🌟 The novel incorporates real elements of Salem's modern witch community, which now numbers over 1,000 practicing Wiccans and has made the city a center for contemporary Pagan religion.