📖 Overview
Pandy Wallis, a successful Manhattan novelist, has built her career on a series of books featuring a beloved character named Monica. The books spawned blockbuster films starring actress Sondra-Beth Schnowzer, who became both Pandy's close friend and the face of Monica for millions of fans.
Following her divorce and seeking a fresh start, Pandy attempts to break free from Monica's shadow to write historical fiction. Her publisher and fans resist this change, leading Pandy to consider permanently ending the Monica series.
The story moves between present-day events and memories of Pandy's past, including her complicated relationship with Sondra-Beth and the dissolution of her marriage. Her literary agent Henry stands by her side as she navigates these professional and personal challenges.
The novel examines the tension between artistic freedom and commercial success, while exploring how fictional characters can overtake their creators' lives. Through Pandy's struggle, the book questions the price of fame and the search for authentic self-expression in the publishing world.
👀 Reviews
Reader reviews for Killing Monica are overwhelmingly negative, with many expressing disappointment given Bushnell's previous work.
Positive comments:
- Fun, escapist beach read
- Captures the energy of New York City
- Contains moments of sharp social satire
Common criticisms:
- Characters are unlikeable and one-dimensional
- Plot is confusing and hard to follow
- Writing style feels scattered and unfocused
- Too many pop culture references that feel forced
Many readers cited specific frustrations with the main character Pandy being "whiny" and "self-absorbed." Multiple reviews mentioned struggling to finish the book or abandoning it partway through.
Ratings:
Goodreads: 2.5/5 (2,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 2.7/5 (200+ ratings)
Barnes & Noble: 2.5/5 (60+ ratings)
Sample reader comment from Goodreads: "This reads like a first draft that needed serious editing. The characters are paper-thin and the plot meanders aimlessly. A major disappointment from an author capable of much better."
📚 Similar books
The Devil Wears Prada by Lauren Weisberger
A writer navigates the cutthroat world of New York media while dealing with a larger-than-life figure who comes to define her professional identity.
Surface Details by Clare Kendal The story follows a novelist whose signature character becomes an obsession for fans and creates a rift between the writer's personal truth and public persona.
The Next Best Thing by Jennifer Weiner The tale of a television writer in Hollywood who must balance creative control with commercial demands as her creation takes on a life beyond her original vision.
Between the Lines by Jodi Picoult A writer grapples with the unexpected consequences when her fictional character begins to impact her real life in ways she never anticipated.
The Plot by Jean Hanff Korelitz A writing professor faces the complications of literary success when a story he claims as his own threatens to unravel his carefully constructed career.
Surface Details by Clare Kendal The story follows a novelist whose signature character becomes an obsession for fans and creates a rift between the writer's personal truth and public persona.
The Next Best Thing by Jennifer Weiner The tale of a television writer in Hollywood who must balance creative control with commercial demands as her creation takes on a life beyond her original vision.
Between the Lines by Jodi Picoult A writer grapples with the unexpected consequences when her fictional character begins to impact her real life in ways she never anticipated.
The Plot by Jean Hanff Korelitz A writing professor faces the complications of literary success when a story he claims as his own threatens to unravel his carefully constructed career.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 The book draws parallels to Bushnell's own experience with "Sex and the City" and her character Carrie Bradshaw, reflecting the complex dynamics between creators and their fictional personas.
📚 Prior to its publication in 2015, the manuscript for "Killing Monica" was reportedly stolen and held for ransom, adding real-life drama to the book's release.
🎭 The novel deliberately plays with meta-fiction elements, as both the author and main character grapple with being overshadowed by their most famous creation.
🗽 The book's New York setting showcases Bushnell's intimate knowledge of Manhattan's elite social circles, gained from her years as a New York Observer columnist.
✍️ While writing this book, Bushnell was going through her own divorce from ballet dancer Charles Askegard, which influenced some of the emotional themes in the story.