📖 Overview
Black Roses follows Paul Ritchie, an English painter who encounters his past while on a Mediterranean cruise. The story alternates between the present and his memories of Naples from decades earlier, where he lived among fellow artists and experienced both friendship and romance.
The narrative centers on three main characters whose lives intersect in Naples during a devastating cholera epidemic. The city of Naples itself serves as a powerful backdrop, with its vibrant artistic community and tumultuous history playing crucial roles in the story.
The tale spans several decades, tracing Ritchie's journey from his youthful experiences in Italy to his later years confronting long-buried memories. The Mediterranean setting draws from Francis Brett Young's own time spent in the region during the 1920s.
This novel examines themes of memory, survival guilt, and the way past traumas can shape a life. Through Ritchie's return to Naples, the story explores how time and distance can help heal old wounds.
👀 Reviews
Limited reader reviews exist online for this 1929 novel, making it difficult to gauge overall reception. The book appears to have fallen into relative obscurity with few modern readers.
Readers who enjoyed it point to:
- Detailed depictions of the English countryside
- The romantic storyline between Philip and Emmy
- Atmospheric descriptions of rural life
Criticisms include:
- Slow pacing in the middle sections
- Dated social attitudes
- Dense prose style typical of the period
Goodreads has no community ratings or reviews for this title. Amazon lists it as currently unavailable with no customer reviews. A 1929 review in The Spectator praised Young's "poetic feeling for landscape" but noted the plot was "somewhat thin."
Note: This response is limited due to the scarcity of available reader reviews. The book seems to have had limited modern readership, making it challenging to provide a comprehensive view of reader reactions.
📚 Similar books
The Bay of Noon by Shirley Hazzard
A woman's immersion into the artistic circles of 1950s Naples reveals the city's power to shape relationships and destinies through intersecting lives of expatriates and locals.
Angels in the Gloom by Charles Todd A World War I veteran confronts his memories of trauma while investigating a murder that forces him to revisit his past experiences in Mediterranean ports.
Those Who Leave and Those Who Stay by Elena Ferrante Two friends navigate the complexities of life, art, and relationships in Naples across multiple decades as their paths diverge and reconnect.
The Story of a New Name by Elena Ferrante The lives of two women in post-war Naples unfold against the backdrop of social change and artistic awakening in the city's vibrant neighborhoods.
In the Company of Strangers by Michael J. Collins An artist's journey through post-war Italy reveals connections between present-day encounters and memories of wartime experiences that shaped his life.
Angels in the Gloom by Charles Todd A World War I veteran confronts his memories of trauma while investigating a murder that forces him to revisit his past experiences in Mediterranean ports.
Those Who Leave and Those Who Stay by Elena Ferrante Two friends navigate the complexities of life, art, and relationships in Naples across multiple decades as their paths diverge and reconnect.
The Story of a New Name by Elena Ferrante The lives of two women in post-war Naples unfold against the backdrop of social change and artistic awakening in the city's vibrant neighborhoods.
In the Company of Strangers by Michael J. Collins An artist's journey through post-war Italy reveals connections between present-day encounters and memories of wartime experiences that shaped his life.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌹 Young spent significant time in Italy himself, living there in the 1920s, which deeply influenced his portrayal of Naples in "Black Roses"
🌹 The novel's treatment of the cholera epidemic was informed by actual outbreaks that occurred in Naples during the late 19th century
🌹 Francis Brett Young trained as a physician before becoming a writer, lending medical authenticity to the disease-related portions of the narrative
🌹 The book's exploration of memory and place was partly inspired by Young's own experiences of returning to locations from his past after long absences
🌹 Published in 1929, "Black Roses" came during a period when novels about British expatriates in Italy were particularly popular, following in the tradition of E.M. Forster's "A Room with a View"