📖 Overview
Rally Cry follows a Union Army regiment and artillery unit that gets mysteriously transported from 1865 Virginia to an alien world called Valennia. The 35th Maine Volunteer Infantry finds themselves in a place where other human civilizations from Earth's past have also appeared, including ancient Romans, medieval Russians, and Carthaginians.
The soldiers must adapt to this strange new world where humans are not the dominant species, but rather face threats from nine-foot-tall alien nomads. This alternate world features Ice Age megafauna, alien creatures, and distinct physical characteristics including lighter gravity and smaller oceans.
The story centers on the regiment's efforts to survive and establish themselves in their new reality, particularly in the territory of Rus where they encounter complex political dynamics between local leaders and the church. The soldiers must leverage their Civil War-era military knowledge and technology to protect both themselves and their new allies.
The novel explores themes of adaptation, survival, and the preservation of civilization in the face of overwhelming odds, while examining how military discipline and leadership operate in extraordinary circumstances.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe Rally Cry as an entertaining military time-travel story that prioritizes action over complex character development. The book maintains a fast pace and focuses on military tactics and battles.
Readers appreciated:
- Detailed military strategy and combat scenes
- Quick pacing with minimal slow sections
- Educational elements about Civil War-era military units
- Balance of historical and science fiction elements
Common criticisms:
- Basic character development
- Simple writing style
- Predictable plot points
- Some historical accuracy issues noted by Civil War enthusiasts
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (1,200+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (300+ ratings)
Several reviewers noted it works well as "military fiction comfort food" but may disappoint readers seeking deeper themes or character exploration. Multiple reviews mentioned the book reads like a "wargame scenario brought to life." Civil War buffs pointed out anachronisms in military equipment descriptions and tactics.
📚 Similar books
1632 by Eric Flint
A small modern American town is transported to 17th century Germany, where the citizens must use their knowledge and technology to survive in a war-torn past.
Island in the Sea of Time by S. M. Stirling The island of Nantucket is sent back to 1250 BC, forcing its inhabitants to rebuild civilization while dealing with Bronze Age cultures.
Rome Sweet Rome by James Erwin A U.S. Marine Expeditionary Unit is transported to ancient Rome and must navigate the complexities of the Roman Empire with modern military capabilities.
The Destroyermen Series: Into the Storm by Taylor Anderson A World War II destroyer and its crew are transported to an alternate Earth where evolution took a different path, leading to warfare with intelligent creatures.
Ranks of Bronze by David Drake Roman legionaries are captured by alien traders and used as mercenaries on low-tech worlds, combining ancient military tactics with interstellar conflicts.
Island in the Sea of Time by S. M. Stirling The island of Nantucket is sent back to 1250 BC, forcing its inhabitants to rebuild civilization while dealing with Bronze Age cultures.
Rome Sweet Rome by James Erwin A U.S. Marine Expeditionary Unit is transported to ancient Rome and must navigate the complexities of the Roman Empire with modern military capabilities.
The Destroyermen Series: Into the Storm by Taylor Anderson A World War II destroyer and its crew are transported to an alternate Earth where evolution took a different path, leading to warfare with intelligent creatures.
Ranks of Bronze by David Drake Roman legionaries are captured by alien traders and used as mercenaries on low-tech worlds, combining ancient military tactics with interstellar conflicts.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 The Lost Regiment series, which begins with Rally Cry, spans nine books total, with the final book "Down to the Sea" published in 2000.
🔹 Author William Forstchen holds a Ph.D. in Military History from Purdue University and has served as a Faculty Fellow at Montreat College in North Carolina.
🔹 The 35th Maine Regiment featured in the book is fictional, but its portrayal is based on actual Civil War-era military units and their documented tactics and structures.
🔹 The alien antagonists, known as the Tugar, are based partly on historical Mongol warriors, featuring similar nomadic culture and military strategies.
🔹 The concept of displaced human civilizations meeting on an alien world was partly inspired by the "lost world" genre popularized by authors like Edgar Rice Burroughs in the early 20th century.