Where Do Camels Belong?

Ken Thompson's Where Do Camels Belong? explores the complex science and politics of invasive species, questioning common assumptions about what makes a species "native" or "alien" to a particular region. The book takes its title from the surprising fact that camels, typically associated with the Middle East, originated in North America. Through detailed case studies and scientific research, Thompson challenges the widespread narrative about invasive species being uniformly harmful to ecosystems. He examines historical species movements, human interventions in various environments, and the often-contradictory approaches to conservation and species management. The work connects invasive species biology to broader themes of environmental change, human impact on nature, and the evolving relationship between science and public policy. Thompson's analysis raises fundamental questions about how humans categorize and value different species in an increasingly interconnected world.

Readers call this an eye-opening look at invasive species that challenges common assumptions. The book has a 3.95/5 rating on Goodreads (87 ratings) and 4.5/5 on Amazon UK (31 ratings). Readers appreciated: - Clear explanations of complex ecological concepts - The questioning of "native vs. invasive" labels - Thompson's use of humor and accessible writing style - Specific case studies and examples Main criticisms: - Too UK/Europe-focused for international readers - Some readers found the tone dismissive of conservation efforts - Repetitive points in later chapters One reader noted: "Made me completely rethink what we mean by 'native' species." Another wrote: "His arguments about arbitrary time periods for nativeness are spot-on." Critics pointed out: "Downplays real environmental damage from certain invasive species" and "Needs more balance between questioning assumptions and acknowledging genuine threats." The book maintains 4+ star ratings across most review platforms despite these concerns.

Invasive Aliens by Dan Eatherley This history of Britain's non-native species explores the intersection of human activity and species migration through documented cases from Roman times to present day.

The New Wild by Fred Pearce The book challenges conventional wisdom about invasive species and presents research suggesting that non-native species create new ecological opportunities.

The Aliens Among Us by Leslie Anthony A global investigation into invasive species combines field research, historical records, and scientific studies to examine their impact on ecosystems.

A Plague of Rats and Rubbervines by Yvonne Baskin The text examines how global trade and travel facilitate species movement across continents and transforms ecosystems.

Never Out of Season by Rob Dunn This exploration of food security and biodiversity demonstrates how monocultures and species movement affect agricultural systems worldwide.

🐪 Camels originated in North America around 45 million years ago, evolving there before spreading to Asia and eventually going extinct in their birthplace. 🌿 The concept of "native" species is relatively modern, largely emerging in the 19th century alongside nationalism and xenophobia in human society. 🔬 Author Ken Thompson is a renowned plant ecologist who spent 20 years as a senior lecturer at the University of Sheffield, specializing in plant ecology and the dynamics of plant populations. 🌍 Many of our most cherished "native" European plants, like the potato and tomato, actually originated in South America and were introduced by humans within the last few centuries. 💰 The global invasive species control industry is worth billions annually, yet research shows that fewer than 1% of introduced species become seriously problematic in their new environments.