What Is Marriage? Man and Woman: A Defense

What Is Marriage? Man and Woman: A Defense presents philosophical arguments supporting traditional marriage between one man and one woman. The authors, led by Robert P. George, examine historical, social, and ethical dimensions of marriage as an institution. The book addresses key debates around marriage definition, responding to arguments for same-sex marriage and other alternative arrangements. It develops a case based on natural law philosophy and social science research regarding family structures and child outcomes. Through logical analysis and engagement with opposing viewpoints, the authors build their defense of traditional marriage across legal, cultural and policy domains. The work includes responses to common counterarguments and examines implications for law and public policy. The book represents a significant contribution to contemporary discourse on marriage, family structures, and the intersection of philosophy with public policy. Its arguments raise fundamental questions about the nature and purpose of marriage as a social institution.

Most readers note this book presents philosophical and legal arguments for defining marriage as between one man and one woman. The writing style is academic and draws heavily on natural law theory. Readers who gave positive reviews appreciated: - Clear logical structure and argumentation - Inclusion of citations and evidence - Focus on secular rather than religious reasoning Common criticisms include: - Dense, complex writing that can be hard to follow - Circular logic in some arguments - Lack of engagement with counter-arguments - Repetitive points Ratings: Amazon: 4.3/5 (236 reviews) Goodreads: 3.8/5 (162 ratings) Specific reader comments: "Rigorous philosophical treatment but needed an editor" - Goodreads reviewer "Makes strong points but ignores key opposing views" - Amazon reviewer "Important contribution to marriage debate despite flaws" - Catholic World Report "Too academic for general readers" - Christianity Today review

The Case for Marriage by Linda Waite, Maggie Gallagher. This research-based examination presents data on marriage as a social institution and its effects on child-rearing, economic stability, and societal structure.

The Meaning of Marriage by Timothy J. Keller. The text explores marriage through philosophical and theological frameworks while addressing contemporary challenges to traditional marriage concepts.

The Future of Marriage by David Blankenhorn. This work examines the historical development of marriage as an institution and analyzes its role in cultural formation and social ordering.

Sex and Culture by J. D. Unwin. This anthropological study investigates the relationship between marriage customs and civilizational development across 86 societies.

Marriage and Civilization by William Tucker. The book traces marriage patterns through human history and connects them to the development of social structures and cultural advancement.

🔹 The book sparked significant academic debate upon its 2012 release, as it presented philosophical arguments for traditional marriage during a pivotal time in the U.S. same-sex marriage discourse, just before several landmark Supreme Court decisions. 🔹 Author Robert P. George is a Princeton University professor who has been called "America's most influential conservative Christian thinker" by The New York Times Magazine. 🔹 The work originated from a 2010 Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy article that became one of the most downloaded academic papers about marriage that year. 🔹 The book's argument centers on what the authors call the "conjugal view" of marriage, which they distinguish from the "revisionist view," using philosophical reasoning rather than religious arguments. 🔹 Despite being controversial, the book has been used as required reading in several university courses on ethics and family law, including at both conservative and liberal institutions.