📖 Overview
The Darkness that Comes Before launches an epic fantasy series set in a world on the brink of holy war. The story follows multiple characters including a warrior-monk, a prostitute-spy, and a sorcerer as they navigate political intrigue and impending conflict across a vast medieval landscape.
The plot centers on the enigmatic Maithanet, a newly appointed religious leader who calls for a great crusade to retake the holy city of Shimeh. Meanwhile, a mysterious figure known as Kellhus emerges from the northern wastes with hidden knowledge and motivations that will impact the entire continent.
The novel combines elements of philosophy, psychology and religious history within its fantasy framework. This first installment sets up complex theological and political systems while introducing characters who must confront questions of free will, manipulation, and belief.
The Darkness that Comes Before examines the nature of consciousness and how the past shapes both individuals and civilizations. Through its exploration of power dynamics, religious fervor, and human nature, the novel challenges conventional fantasy tropes while raising fundamental questions about knowledge and truth.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe the book as dense and philosophical, with complex worldbuilding and political intrigue. Many compare it to Dune in scope and depth.
Readers appreciated:
- The magic system's metaphysical foundations
- Historical authenticity in depicting religious/political conflicts
- Deep psychological exploration of characters
- Unique take on prophecy and determinism
Common criticisms:
- Slow pacing in first 200 pages
- Many unfamiliar terms/names without explanation
- Limited female character development
- Philosophy passages can interrupt story flow
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (15,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.2/5 (500+ ratings)
Sample reader comments:
"Like reading ancient history rather than fantasy" - Goodreads
"Requires work but rewards patience" - Amazon
"Too much exposition dumps early on" - Fantasy Faction forum
"Characters feel real but hard to connect with emotionally" - r/Fantasy
📚 Similar books
Gardens of the Moon by Steven Erikson
The first book in the Malazan series presents a complex philosophical fantasy world with multiple plotlines, ancient powers, and political machinations that mirror the depth found in The Darkness that Comes Before.
Prince of Nothing by Glen Cook This military fantasy follows a mercenary company through dark conflicts and complex power structures while exploring themes of manipulation and destiny.
The Blade Itself by Joe Abercrombie The book weaves together perspectives of morally ambiguous characters in a gritty world where philosophy and violence intersect with politics and power.
The Dragon's Path by Daniel Abraham This series opener builds a richly detailed world where banking houses and political factions vie for control while ancient powers stir beneath the surface.
The Court of Broken Knives by Anna Smith Spark The narrative follows multiple characters through a brutal world of political intrigue and philosophical discourse while examining the nature of power and empire.
Prince of Nothing by Glen Cook This military fantasy follows a mercenary company through dark conflicts and complex power structures while exploring themes of manipulation and destiny.
The Blade Itself by Joe Abercrombie The book weaves together perspectives of morally ambiguous characters in a gritty world where philosophy and violence intersect with politics and power.
The Dragon's Path by Daniel Abraham This series opener builds a richly detailed world where banking houses and political factions vie for control while ancient powers stir beneath the surface.
The Court of Broken Knives by Anna Smith Spark The narrative follows multiple characters through a brutal world of political intrigue and philosophical discourse while examining the nature of power and empire.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 The name "Dûnyain" in the novel comes from the Arabic word "dunya," meaning "world" or "earthly existence"
🖋️ R. Scott Bakker originally conceived the story while working on his Ph.D. in philosophy, incorporating complex philosophical themes into the narrative
🏰 The ancient city of Atrithau in the novel was inspired by the real-world ancient city of Petra in Jordan
💭 The book explores the concept of the "Logos" from Greek philosophy, which represents divine reason and the organizing principle of the universe
🗺️ The Three Seas region in the novel draws parallels to the historical Mediterranean world during the First Crusade, blending historical elements with fantasy