📖 Overview
New Witnesses for God is a three-volume theological work published between 1895-1909 by Mormon leader and historian B.H. Roberts. The books present arguments and evidence for the authenticity of the Book of Mormon and the prophetic mission of Joseph Smith.
Volume I focuses on establishing theological foundations and discussing the role of witnesses in religious truth claims. Volumes II and III examine the Book of Mormon in detail, analyzing its origins, historical context, and internal consistency.
Through systematic argumentation and historical analysis, Roberts addresses criticisms of Mormon scripture while building a case for its divine origins. The work combines scriptural examination, historical research, and philosophical reasoning to construct its theological framework.
The text represents an early example of Mormon apologetics and demonstrates the intersection of faith and intellectual discourse in early 20th century Latter-day Saint thought. Its approach to reconciling religious claims with rational inquiry influenced later Mormon theological scholarship.
👀 Reviews
Limited review data exists online for this 1895 theological work by B.H. Roberts. The few available reader reviews focus on the book's defense of the Book of Mormon and examination of its historical evidence.
Readers valued:
- Detailed analysis of Native American origins
- Historical context for Mormon scripture
- Roberts' systematic approach to addressing criticisms
Readers disliked:
- Dense, academic writing style
- Outdated 19th century language
- Some arguments haven't held up to modern scholarship
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.17/5 (6 ratings, 0 written reviews)
Amazon: No ratings or reviews available
Archive.org: 0 reviews
One reader on a Mormon discussion forum noted: "Roberts presents thorough research for his time period, though some conclusions have been superseded by archaeological findings." Another commented that "the historical background provides valuable context for understanding early Mormon apologetics."
The book receives minimal modern discussion outside academic Mormon studies.
📚 Similar books
Evidence and Reconciliations by John A. Widtsoe
This book examines Mormon doctrine through historical documentation and scholarly analysis of religious principles.
Jesus the Christ by James E. Talmage The text presents historical context and doctrinal examination of Jesus Christ's life through both biblical and Mormon theological perspectives.
Articles of Faith by James E. Talmage The work provides systematic explanations of Mormon theological principles with references to scripture and historical sources.
The Truth, The Way, The Life by B.H. Roberts This theological treatise combines scientific thought with religious doctrine to explain Mormon cosmology and religious principles.
Mormon Doctrine by Bruce R. McConkie The text presents encyclopedic explanations of Mormon theology with references to scripture, church history, and doctrinal interpretations.
Jesus the Christ by James E. Talmage The text presents historical context and doctrinal examination of Jesus Christ's life through both biblical and Mormon theological perspectives.
Articles of Faith by James E. Talmage The work provides systematic explanations of Mormon theological principles with references to scripture and historical sources.
The Truth, The Way, The Life by B.H. Roberts This theological treatise combines scientific thought with religious doctrine to explain Mormon cosmology and religious principles.
Mormon Doctrine by Bruce R. McConkie The text presents encyclopedic explanations of Mormon theology with references to scripture, church history, and doctrinal interpretations.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔖 B. H. Roberts wrote "New Witnesses for God" while serving time in the Utah State Prison for practicing plural marriage, completing much of the manuscript during his six-month incarceration in 1889.
📚 The book was published in three volumes between 1895 and 1909, with Volume I focusing on Joseph Smith as a witness for God, and Volumes II and III examining the Book of Mormon.
⚜️ Roberts was one of the first Mormon scholars to address potential historical anachronisms in the Book of Mormon, tackling challenging topics that many others avoided at the time.
📖 The work represents one of the earliest systematic defenses of Mormonism by a Mormon intellectual, combining historical research, theological argument, and literary analysis.
🎓 Despite having no formal education beyond elementary school, Roberts became known as "Defender of the Faith" largely due to this and other scholarly works, eventually being considered one of Mormonism's most important intellectual figures.