The Politics of Suffering: Indigenous Australia and the End of the Liberal Consensus

Peter Sutton's The Politics of Suffering examines Indigenous policy in Australia and challenges the progressive consensus that emerged in the 1970s. The book draws on Sutton's four decades of experience as an anthropologist working with Aboriginal communities. Sutton documents the deterioration of conditions in many Indigenous communities despite well-intentioned policy interventions. He presents case studies and data to analyze the gap between policy ideals and on-the-ground realities in areas including health, violence, and social breakdown. The book moves through key debates around self-determination, land rights, and the role of customary law in contemporary Indigenous life. Sutton's firsthand observations from remote communities inform his critique of both conservative and progressive approaches to Indigenous affairs. This work raises fundamental questions about the intersection of cultural relativism, human rights, and practical policy-making in addressing Indigenous disadvantage. The analysis challenges readers to move beyond ideological positions and confront complex realities about what has and hasn't worked in Indigenous policy.

Readers view this book as a critique of progressive policies toward Indigenous Australians, based on Sutton's anthropological work. Many note his firsthand experience and academic credentials add weight to his arguments. Liked: - Detailed analysis backed by research and personal observations - Clear writing style that makes complex topics accessible - Balanced perspective that looks at multiple policy approaches Disliked: - Some found it too academic and dense - Critics say it oversimplifies certain cultural dynamics - Several readers wanted more proposed solutions Review scores: Goodreads: 3.8/5 (21 ratings) Amazon AU: 4.2/5 (6 ratings) Notable reader comments: "Challenges comfortable assumptions about Indigenous policy" - Goodreads reviewer "Important but difficult read that forces uncomfortable questions" - Amazon reviewer "Would have benefited from more Indigenous voices and perspectives" - LibraryThing reviewer The limited number of online reviews suggests this book reached a primarily academic audience.

Why Warriors Lie Down and Die by Richard Trudgen An examination of the cultural disconnect between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians through the lens of health and social services in Arnhem Land.

The White Possessive by Aileen Moreton-Robinson An analysis of how race and white possession shape Australian society and Indigenous-settler relations through law, culture, and knowledge production.

Throwing Off the Cloak by Elizabeth Povinelli An ethnographic study of Indigenous Australians in the Northern Territory that explores the tensions between traditional practices and modern governance.

My Place by Sally Morgan A personal account of discovering Aboriginal identity in Western Australia that illuminates the impacts of colonial policies on Indigenous families.

Whitewash: On Keith Windschuttle's Fabrication of Aboriginal History by Robert Manne A critique of historical revisionism that examines the contested nature of Indigenous Australian historiography and the politics of truth-telling.

🔷 Peter Sutton spent over 50 years working with Aboriginal communities as an anthropologist and linguist, giving him unique firsthand insights into the issues he discusses in the book. 🔷 The book was written partly in response to the 2007 Northern Territory Intervention, a controversial government policy that increased federal control over Aboriginal communities. 🔷 Sutton challenges both conservative and progressive approaches to Indigenous policy, arguing that ideological positions on both sides have failed to address real problems facing Aboriginal communities. 🔷 The author's perspective shifted dramatically after witnessing the deaths of several Aboriginal friends due to violence in their communities, leading him to reassess his previous support for self-determination policies. 🔷 The book won the 2010 John Button Prize for writing on public policy and politics, sparking intense debate within academic and policy circles about Indigenous affairs in Australia.