📖 Overview
An Honorable Profession follows Miles Bannon, a respected high school English teacher in Boston whose life becomes increasingly complex as he grapples with his mother's illness and questions about his sexual identity. The narrative centers on his relationships with his girlfriend Margaret, his students, and his conflicted feelings about a brief encounter with a man named Robert.
The story takes a dark turn when a troubled student named Billy Mack, already dealing with trauma from a sexual assault, develops an attachment to Miles. Billy's police officer father Jack harbors his own prejudices and anger about his son's situation, creating additional tension within the community.
When tragedy strikes, Miles must navigate false accusations, small-town prejudice, and intense media scrutiny while confronting fundamental questions about his own identity and place in society. The novel combines elements of psychological drama and social commentary in its examination of sexuality, professional ethics, and personal truth.
👀 Reviews
Readers found this novel about a Catholic priest teaching at a prep school to be emotionally complex but slow-paced. Many reviews note L'Heureux's nuanced exploration of faith, morality and human relationships.
Readers appreciated:
- Depth of character development
- Realistic portrayal of Catholic school culture
- Thoughtful handling of religious themes
Common criticisms:
- Pacing drags in middle sections
- Some found the protagonist difficult to empathize with
- Religious elements too heavy-handed for some readers
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (47 ratings)
Amazon: 4.2/5 (12 reviews)
Notable reader comments:
"Captures the complexities of faith and doubt without preaching" - Goodreads reviewer
"Strong writing but moves too slowly" - Amazon reviewer
"Characters feel authentic but story meanders" - Kirkus reader review
The book appears to resonate most with readers interested in literary fiction dealing with religious themes and moral questions.
📚 Similar books
The Art of Teaching by Gilbert Highet
This memoir chronicles a professor's experiences and reflections on academia while exploring the complex relationships between teachers and students.
Stoner by John Williams The life story of a university professor unfolds against the backdrop of academic politics and personal struggles in mid-twentieth century America.
Straight Man by Richard Russo A college English department chairman navigates institutional chaos, budget cuts, and personal crises during one tumultuous week in Pennsylvania.
The Human Stain by Philip Roth A classics professor's life unravels amid scandal and racial politics at a New England college in the 1990s.
Nice Work by David Lodge A feminist literary theorist and an industrial firm manager cross paths in this examination of academia versus industry in Thatcher's Britain.
Stoner by John Williams The life story of a university professor unfolds against the backdrop of academic politics and personal struggles in mid-twentieth century America.
Straight Man by Richard Russo A college English department chairman navigates institutional chaos, budget cuts, and personal crises during one tumultuous week in Pennsylvania.
The Human Stain by Philip Roth A classics professor's life unravels amid scandal and racial politics at a New England college in the 1990s.
Nice Work by David Lodge A feminist literary theorist and an industrial firm manager cross paths in this examination of academia versus industry in Thatcher's Britain.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎓 John L'Heureux taught in the English Department at Stanford University for 36 years and directed their prestigious Creative Writing Program.
📚 Before becoming a writer, L'Heureux was a Jesuit priest for 17 years before leaving the priesthood to pursue a career in literature.
🏛️ The New England setting of the novel draws from L'Heureux's own background - he was born in South Hadley, Massachusetts and taught at Harvard University.
📖 The book was published in 1991, during a period of significant social change in America regarding LGBTQ+ rights and visibility in education.
🏆 L'Heureux's work has received numerous accolades, including grants from the National Endowment for the Arts and the Guggenheim Foundation, lending credibility to his careful handling of sensitive subject matter.