Against Everything

Against Everything is a collection of essays examining modern American life and cultural practices through a critical lens. The essays tackle subjects ranging from food culture and exercise to popular music and the meaning of life itself. The book moves through analysis of everyday activities and social phenomena, questioning assumptions about how we live and why we make certain choices. Greif challenges conventional wisdom about topics like healthy eating, youth culture, and the role of consumption in society. Each essay builds on themes of authenticity, pleasure, and the disconnect between human desires and contemporary lifestyles. The writing combines cultural criticism with philosophical inquiry to address fundamental questions about modern existence. The collection serves as both critique and investigation of what it means to live meaningfully in an era dominated by capitalism, self-optimization, and mediated experiences. Through precise observations and historical context, Greif raises questions about widely accepted behaviors and institutional forces that shape daily life.

Readers describe this essay collection as intellectually dense cultural criticism that examines modern life's routines and assumptions. Many appreciate Greif's analytical approach to everyday topics like exercise, food, music, and sex. Positive reviews highlight: - Fresh perspectives on familiar subjects - Academic rigor and philosophical depth - Clear writing style despite complex ideas Common criticisms: - Arguments can feel pretentious or overthought - Some essays meander without clear conclusions - Academic tone can be dry and inaccessible Ratings: Goodreads: 3.7/5 (446 ratings) Amazon: 3.8/5 (31 ratings) Several readers note the strongest essays are "Against Exercise" and "On Food." One Amazon reviewer writes: "Greif takes mundane aspects of life and excavates their deeper meaning." A frequent Goodreads criticism is that Greif "sometimes creates problems where none exist" and "overanalyzes simple pleasures." Multiple reviewers suggest reading individual essays rather than cover-to-cover.

The Argonauts by Maggie Nelson This memoir-philosophy hybrid examines contemporary life through critical theory and personal experience while challenging cultural assumptions about gender, sexuality, and family structures.

Reality Hunger by David Shields The book dissects modern media culture and challenges traditional narrative forms through a collection of numbered fragments that merge criticism, autobiography, and cultural commentary.

The Art of Cruelty by Maggie Nelson This examination of violence in art and media questions the role of brutality in culture while analyzing works across literature, film, and visual art.

Notes from No Man's Land by Eula Biss These essays investigate American identity through the lens of race, class, and privilege while connecting personal experiences to broader social structures.

The White Album by Joan Didion This collection of essays captures the cultural shifts of the 1960s and 1970s through precise observations of American social phenomena and institutions.

🔹 Mark Greif co-founded the influential literary magazine n+1 in 2004, which has published works by prominent writers like Jonathan Franzen and Rebecca Solnit 🔹 The essays in "Against Everything" began as columns for n+1 called "The Meaning of Life," where Greif explored everyday modern phenomena from exercise to reality TV 🔹 Despite its seemingly negative title, the book isn't about pure opposition - Greif has explained it's about questioning the things we take for granted in contemporary life 🔹 The author wrote much of the book while teaching at The New School in New York City, an institution known for its progressive approach to social research and critical theory 🔹 The book's critique of food culture and "foodism" sparked significant debate in literary circles and was widely discussed in publications like The New Yorker and The Atlantic