📖 Overview
So This Is Ever After follows Arek, a teenager who fulfilled a prophecy by defeating the evil king. After claiming the throne, Arek learns he must find a spouse before his upcoming birthday or face death due to an ancient magical curse.
With help from his close friend and mage Matt, Arek attempts to navigate potential romances with members of his former questing party while learning to rule a kingdom. The story takes place entirely after the traditional hero's journey, focusing on what happens when the prophecy is complete but real life continues.
Political intrigues and magical complications arise as Arek balances his search for love with his new royal responsibilities. His relationships with his former companions evolve and deepen as they settle into their post-quest roles in the castle.
The novel explores themes of identity, found family, and the reality that achieving a destined goal doesn't automatically provide a clear path forward. Through its genre-aware approach, the story challenges fantasy conventions while celebrating the importance of genuine connection.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a lighthearted romantic comedy that puts a queer spin on "what happens after the quest." Many note it reads like fanfiction in tone and style, which some consider a strength and others a weakness.
Readers appreciated:
- The humorous dialogue and banter
- LGBTQ+ representation in a fantasy setting
- The found family dynamics
- References to fantasy tropes and clichés
Common criticisms:
- Plot feels thin and repetitive
- Romance develops slowly
- Character development lacks depth
- Writing style can be simplistic
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (12,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (500+ ratings)
StoryGraph: 3.75/5
Review quotes:
"Like comfort food in book form" - Goodreads reviewer
"Fun but forgettable" - Amazon reviewer
"Perfect for fans of In Other Lands who want more awkward disaster gays doing their best" - StoryGraph reviewer
📚 Similar books
In Deeper Waters by F.T. Lukens
A prince finds romance with a mysterious prisoner during a coming-of-age sea voyage while navigating royal responsibilities and magical threats.
The Sunbearer Trials by Aiden Thomas Two boys compete in trials to determine who will sacrifice their life force to fuel the sun god's power, combining competition, prophecy, and queer romance.
In the Lives of Puppets by TJ Klune A reimagining of Pinocchio follows an android who builds a found family in a hidden forest sanctuary while protecting his human son from mechanical hunters.
The Midnight Girls by Alicia Jasinska Two rival witches who harvest the hearts of princes to gain power find themselves drawn to each other despite their deadly competition.
The Darkening by Sunya Mara A girl infiltrates her city's ruling class to save her father and stop a supernatural storm that turns people into shadow creatures.
The Sunbearer Trials by Aiden Thomas Two boys compete in trials to determine who will sacrifice their life force to fuel the sun god's power, combining competition, prophecy, and queer romance.
In the Lives of Puppets by TJ Klune A reimagining of Pinocchio follows an android who builds a found family in a hidden forest sanctuary while protecting his human son from mechanical hunters.
The Midnight Girls by Alicia Jasinska Two rival witches who harvest the hearts of princes to gain power find themselves drawn to each other despite their deadly competition.
The Darkening by Sunya Mara A girl infiltrates her city's ruling class to save her father and stop a supernatural storm that turns people into shadow creatures.
🤔 Interesting facts
⚔️ The book's premise flips traditional fairytale endings by starting where most stories end - after the hero has defeated the Dark Lord and claimed the kingdom.
🏰 Author F.T. Lukens drew inspiration from both traditional fantasy tropes and romantic comedies to create the novel's unique blend of magic and romance.
👑 The magical contract at the center of the story gives protagonist Arek just 30 days to find a spouse before he'll die - putting a literal deadline on the "happily ever after."
🌈 The novel features LGBTQ+ representation in a fantasy setting, with a gay main character and diverse supporting cast.
✨ The magic system in the book includes specialized abilities based on the four classical elements: earth, air, fire, and water, plus a rare fifth element of spirit magic.