📖 Overview
12: The Inside Story of Tom Brady's Fight for Redemption chronicles the events surrounding the "Deflategate" controversy and its aftermath. The book follows Brady's legal battle against the NFL and Commissioner Roger Goodell after accusations of tampering with football air pressure levels during the 2015 AFC Championship game.
Authors Casey Sherman and Dave Wedge present interviews, court documents, and behind-the-scenes accounts from key figures involved in the scandal. Their reporting covers the initial accusations, the Wells Report investigation, multiple appeal processes, and Brady's eventual four-game suspension.
The narrative tracks Brady's response to the controversy both on and off the field, including his legal strategy and continued performance with the New England Patriots. The book examines the relationships between NFL leadership, team ownership, and players during this period of conflict.
The work stands as an examination of power dynamics in professional sports and the intersection of media, law, and athletics. Through Brady's story, broader themes of reputation management and institutional authority emerge.
👀 Reviews
Readers consider this a surface-level retelling of the Deflategate scandal that doesn't reveal much new information. The book compiles existing media coverage and public records rather than providing fresh insights or behind-the-scenes access.
Readers appreciated:
- Clear chronological organization of events
- Inclusion of court documents and legal details
- Balance in presenting multiple perspectives
- Fast-paced writing style
Common criticisms:
- Lack of original reporting or interviews
- Heavy reliance on already-published sources
- No direct input from Brady or key NFL figures
- Some factual errors in football details
- Repetitive content that drags in middle sections
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.6/5 (500+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (300+ ratings)
Several readers noted the book reads "more like a long magazine article" and "adds nothing new to what was already reported." One reviewer summarized: "If you followed the scandal in real-time, you won't learn anything you don't already know."
📚 Similar books
Belichick: The Making of the Greatest Football Coach of All Time by Ian O'Connor
Documents Bill Belichick's rise through NFL coaching ranks and his relationship with Tom Brady during the Patriots dynasty.
The QB: The Making of Modern Quarterbacks by Bruce Feldman Takes readers into the world of quarterback development and chronicles the evolution of the position through case studies of NFL stars.
Brady vs Manning: The Untold Story of the Rivalry That Transformed the NFL by Gary Myers Chronicles the parallel careers and competitive relationship between Tom Brady and Peyton Manning through interviews and behind-the-scenes accounts.
The Dynasty by Jeff Benedict Details the inner workings of the New England Patriots organization during their dominant two-decade run through interviews with players, coaches, and executives.
The Big Game: The NFL in Dangerous Times by Mark Leibovich Examines the NFL's recent history through access to owners, players, and league officials during a period of controversy and change.
The QB: The Making of Modern Quarterbacks by Bruce Feldman Takes readers into the world of quarterback development and chronicles the evolution of the position through case studies of NFL stars.
Brady vs Manning: The Untold Story of the Rivalry That Transformed the NFL by Gary Myers Chronicles the parallel careers and competitive relationship between Tom Brady and Peyton Manning through interviews and behind-the-scenes accounts.
The Dynasty by Jeff Benedict Details the inner workings of the New England Patriots organization during their dominant two-decade run through interviews with players, coaches, and executives.
The Big Game: The NFL in Dangerous Times by Mark Leibovich Examines the NFL's recent history through access to owners, players, and league officials during a period of controversy and change.
🤔 Interesting facts
🏈 Tom Brady's legal team spent over $7 million fighting the Deflategate accusations, while the NFL spent an estimated $12.5 million pursuing the case.
📚 Author Casey Sherman previously wrote "The Finest Hours," which became a Disney film starring Chris Pine and Casey Affleck in 2016.
🏆 The book reveals that Brady's suspension actually helped him extend his career, as the four-game break in 2016 gave his body crucial rest time at age 39.
⚖️ During the Deflategate investigation, Brady's cell phone became a major point of contention after he destroyed it—the book details that this was his regular practice every time he upgraded phones.
🔍 Sherman conducted over 100 interviews for the book, including conversations with NFL officials, Patriots personnel, and members of Brady's inner circle, though Brady himself declined to participate.