Amateur: A True Story About What Makes a Man

Amateur follows Thomas Page McBee's journey to become the first transgender man to box at Madison Square Garden. McBee trains at a boxing gym in preparation for a charity match, while exploring questions about masculinity, violence, and identity. The memoir documents McBee's experiences both in and out of the ring as he navigates male spaces and confronts societal expectations about manhood. His dual perspective as someone who has lived as both a woman and a man provides unique insights into gender dynamics and male behavior. Throughout his training, McBee interviews experts, athletes, and other men about aggression, competition, and what it means to be "a real man." The narrative weaves together personal reflection with cultural commentary on toxic masculinity and male socialization. The book transcends the typical sports memoir format to examine broader questions about gender performance and authentic selfhood. McBee's story challenges conventional narratives about masculinity while offering a vulnerable exploration of identity transformation.

Readers describe McBee's memoir as an intimate look at masculinity through his experience as a trans man training to become the first transgender boxer to fight at Madison Square Garden. Readers appreciated: - The nuanced exploration of male privilege and gender roles - Clear, precise writing style - Personal reflections balanced with sociological research - Focus on universal questions about identity - Brief length that keeps the narrative focused Common criticisms: - Some readers wanted more detail about the boxing storyline - A few found the academic references disruptive to the personal narrative - Some wished for more emotional depth in certain sections Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (2,800+ ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (115+ ratings) Reader quote: "McBee manages to pack more insight about masculinity into 200 pages than most books triple the length" - Goodreads reviewer The book resonates particularly with readers interested in gender studies, sports memoirs, and LGBTQ+ perspectives.

Man Alive: A True Story of Violence, Forgiveness and Becoming a Man by Thomas Page McBee A trans writer chronicles his journey through trauma, masculinity, and forgiveness as he transitions from female to male.

Real Man Adventures by T Cooper A multimedia memoir combines essays, interviews, and art to explore the experiences of being a trans man in America.

Body Alchemy: Transsexual Portraits by Loren Cameron Through photography and personal narratives, trans men share their stories of transformation and self-discovery.

The Women I Think About at Night by Mia Kankimäki A female writer travels the world to research historical women who defied gender expectations and societal norms.

Self-Made Man: One Woman's Year Disguised as a Man by Norah Vincent A female journalist lives as a man for eighteen months to understand male experiences and gender dynamics in different social spheres.

🥊 Thomas Page McBee became the first openly transgender man to box in Madison Square Garden, competing in a charity match in 2016 at the historic venue. 📝 The book explores masculinity through the lens of McBee's preparation for this boxing match, while simultaneously investigating why men fight and what compels them toward violence. 🏆 "Amateur" was shortlisted for the 2018 Baillie Gifford Prize for Non-Fiction, one of the most prestigious awards for non-fiction writing in the UK. 🎭 Before transitioning, McBee worked as a crime reporter in Massachusetts, an experience that shaped his understanding of masculine violence and informed much of his writing. 💫 The book's title "Amateur" carries dual meaning - referring both to McBee's status as a novice boxer and to the Latin root of the word (amator), which means "lover," suggesting a more compassionate approach to understanding masculinity.