Imaginary Girls

Chloe is fiercely devoted to her older sister Ruby, who seems to have an otherworldly control over their small reservoir town in upstate New York. After a tragic incident forces Chloe to leave town, she returns two years later to find things both familiar and unsettling. The sisters' complicated relationship forms the core of this supernatural mystery, as Chloe grapples with Ruby's apparent ability to bend reality and people to her will. The reservoir that flooded their valley decades ago holds secrets beneath its surface, and questions emerge about what is real and what exists only in stories. The novel blends elements of magical realism with a coming-of-age narrative, exploring the bonds between sisters and the power of belief. Through Chloe's eyes, readers encounter a world where memory, truth, and fiction intersect in unexpected ways. The story examines themes of loyalty, identity, and the stories we tell ourselves to make sense of the inexplicable. It raises questions about the nature of love and whether devotion can sometimes come at too high a cost.

Readers describe this as a haunting and dreamlike story that blurs reality with magical realism. Many note feeling confused but captivated by the atmospheric prose and unreliable narration. Readers praise: - The unique sister relationship dynamics - Vivid descriptions of the reservoir setting - Nova Ren Suma's lyrical writing style - The eerie, supernatural atmosphere Common criticisms: - Plot feels too vague and unresolved - Slow pacing, especially in middle sections - Characters come across as one-dimensional - Too many questions left unanswered Ratings: Goodreads: 3.6/5 (12,000+ ratings) Amazon: 3.7/5 (115 ratings) "Beautiful writing but the story left me frustrated," notes one Goodreads reviewer. Another states: "The prose is gorgeous but the plot meanders without purpose." Several readers mention abandoning the book partway through due to confusion, while others praise it specifically for its dreamy ambiguity.

The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer by Sarah Hodkin A teenage girl uncovers dark truths about herself and her town while dealing with unexplained deaths and supernatural occurrences.

We Were Liars by E. Lockhart The story follows a privileged teenage girl's search for truth about a mysterious accident on her family's private island, blending reality with psychological elements.

Tiger Lily by Jodi Lynn Anderson This retelling of Peter Pan from Tiger Lily's perspective explores sister relationships and dark magic in a setting where reality bends.

The Walls Around Us by Nova Ren Suma Two ballerinas become entangled in a ghost story that connects a juvenile detention center to their dance studio through supernatural events.

The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender by Leslye Walton A multi-generational tale combines magical realism with family secrets to tell the story of a girl born with wings.

🌊 Author Nova Ren Suma wrote portions of Imaginary Girls while living in an artists' residency at Yaddo, a historic estate in Saratoga Springs, NY, where many renowned authors have crafted their works. 🌙 The book's haunting atmosphere was inspired by the real-life Ashokan Reservoir in New York's Catskill Mountains, which submerged several towns when it was created to supply water to New York City. 💫 The novel combines elements of magical realism with contemporary young adult fiction, helping establish Suma's signature style of blending reality with the supernatural. 👯‍♀️ The complex sister relationship at the heart of the story was partially influenced by Suma's own experience as an older sister, though she emphasizes the story is entirely fictional. 🎨 The original cover design features underwater photography, which required specialized equipment and techniques to capture the ethereal effect the publisher wanted for the book.