Broken Ground

Detective Chief Inspector Karen Pirie investigates a decades-old case when a body is discovered in the Scottish Highlands, preserved in a peat bog. The investigation connects to wartime activities from the 1940s and leads Pirie through layers of history and deception. While pursuing this cold case, Pirie must also handle her current duties as head of Historic Cases Unit in Police Scotland. Her investigation reveals connections between past crimes and present dangers, forcing her to navigate both timeframes to uncover the truth. The story moves between the contemporary police investigation and events from World War II, exploring Scotland's wartime activities and their lingering impact. Multiple narrative threads intersect as Pirie pieces together fragments of evidence from different eras. The novel examines themes of memory, consequence, and how the past continues to influence the present. Through its exploration of buried secrets - both literal and metaphorical - the story raises questions about justice and whether some truths are better left undiscovered.

Readers found this Karen Pirie installment delivered a solid police procedural with two parallel investigations - a World War II mystery and a present-day murder case. Liked: - Complex but clear plotting between the timelines - Historical details about post-WWII Scotland - Character development of DCI Pirie - Focus on forensic evidence and procedure - Pacing in the modern investigation sections Disliked: - Slow start with extensive historical background - Too much time spent on Karen's personal life/relationships - Historical storyline less engaging than modern case - Some found the ending rushed and unsatisfying Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (8,900+ ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (2,800+ ratings) Common reader comments note the book "requires patience early on" but "picks up momentum." Multiple reviews praised the "meticulous research" while criticizing "meandering passages about Karen's domestic scenes." Several mentioned struggling with the dual timeline structure initially before getting invested in both stories.

In The Woods by Tana French A Dublin detective investigates a child's murder that mirrors his own childhood trauma, blending police procedural with psychological depth.

The Distant Echo by Ian Rankin Four students become suspects in a woman's murder, and decades later the cold case resurfaces with deadly consequences.

The Crossing Places by Elly Griffiths A forensic archaeologist works with police to uncover the connection between two missing girls in Norfolk's haunting saltmarsh landscape.

The Crow Trap by Ann Cleeves Three women conducting an environmental survey in Northumberland become entangled in a murder investigation that reveals buried secrets.

The Last Place You Look by Kristen Lepionka A private investigator reopens a fifteen-year-old murder case while confronting corruption in a small Ohio town.

🔍 Author Val McDermid has been nicknamed the "Queen of Crime" in the UK and has sold over 17 million copies of her books worldwide. 📚 "Broken Ground" is the fifth book in the Karen Pirie series, featuring a cold case specialist who works for Police Scotland's Historic Cases Unit. ⏳ The novel's plot revolves around a World War II motorcycle discovered in a Highland peat bog, connecting a modern murder to events from 1944. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 The book's atmospheric Highland setting draws from McDermid's intimate knowledge of Scotland, where she was born and studied at St Hilda's College, Oxford as one of the first women admitted. 🎭 Before becoming a crime writer, Val McDermid worked as a journalist and was the first woman from a Scottish state school to be admitted to St Hilda's College.