The Right to Maim

The Right to Maim examines disability, debilitation, and biopolitics through the lens of Israeli occupation in Palestine. Puar introduces the concept of "the right to maim" - a state power framework that involves deliberate injury and incapacitation of populations. The book analyzes how occupation functions through the calculated creation of disability and debility, rather than outright killing. Through case studies and theoretical analysis, Puar explores Palestine-Israel relations, U.S. police violence against Black communities, and other manifestations of state power over bodies. The work draws connections between disability rights, theories of necropolitics, and the global implications of manufactured debility. Puar examines humanitarian responses, infrastructure destruction, and access to healthcare as components of systematic population control. The Right to Maim challenges conventional frameworks of disability theory and biopolitics, presenting debilitation as a modern tool of colonial occupation and population management. The book's analysis raises fundamental questions about sovereignty, human rights, and the politics of injury in contemporary geopolitics.

Readers note the book's academic density and theoretical complexity. Many found the analysis of disability rights, Israeli policy, and biopolitics thought-provoking, though challenging to follow without prior knowledge of critical theory. Liked: - Detailed research and documentation - New perspectives on disability studies - Connections between seemingly disparate topics Disliked: - Dense academic language and jargon - Assumes significant background knowledge - Some readers felt conclusions were predetermined - Writing style described as "needlessly obtuse" One reader noted: "Important ideas buried under impenetrable prose." Another wrote: "Makes valid points about debilitation as a political tool but takes 200 pages to explain what could be said in 20." Ratings: Goodreads: 4.19/5 (54 ratings) Amazon: 3.7/5 (6 reviews) Most academic reviewers engage with the theoretical framework, while general readers focus on accessibility concerns. Several note the book works better as a series of connected essays than a cohesive argument.

Terrorist Assemblages by Jasbir K. Puar A critique of homonationalism and biopolitics through the lens of race, sexuality, and nationalism in post-9/11 America.

The New Way of the World by Pierre Dardot, Christian Laval An examination of neoliberalism as a system of governance that shapes human subjects and social relations through market rationality.

Captive Genders by Eric Stanley, Nat Smith An intersection of trans politics and prison abolition that explores state violence against gender-nonconforming bodies.

Ugly Feelings by Sianne Ngai A study of negative affects and their relationship to political and social marginalization in contemporary culture.

Frames of War by Judith Butler An analysis of how media frames determine which lives are considered grievable and worthy of protection in times of conflict.

🔹 Jasbir K. Puar coined the term "homonationalism" to describe how LGBTQ+ rights are sometimes used to justify nationalist and imperialist policies 🔹 The book challenges traditional disability rights frameworks by examining how certain populations are deliberately "debilitated" rather than completely eliminated through state violence 🔹 The author's research included extensive fieldwork in Palestine, analyzing how Israeli military practices intentionally cause injuries that create long-term disabilities 🔹 The Right to Maim builds on Achille Mbembe's concept of "necropolitics" by introducing "debilitation" as a form of biopolitical control that exists between life and death 🔹 Puar's work has influenced both queer theory and disability studies, creating new conversations about the intersection of sexuality, disability, race, and state power