The Mermaid's Sister

Clara and Maren are sisters raised by an herbalist aunt on Llanfair Mountain. While Clara emerged from a stork basket as a baby, Maren arrived in a seashell - and now she is slowly transforming into a mermaid. The sisters embark on a journey with their friend O'Neill to save Maren before her transformation is complete. Their quest takes them through 19th century Pennsylvania as they search for a way to prevent Maren from dying on dry land. Danger and deception confront the travelers as they encounter a traveling medicine show and its mysterious proprietor. Clara must protect her sister while questioning her own identity and place in the world. This young adult fantasy explores themes of identity, sacrifice, and the unbreakable bonds between siblings. The story challenges assumptions about destiny and belonging while remaining grounded in familial love.

Most readers describe this as a charming YA fantasy with strong themes of sisterly love, though some note it moves slowly in the middle sections. Readers appreciated: - The unique premise and fairy tale atmosphere - Sister relationship dynamics - Clean content suitable for younger teens - Noble's descriptive writing style - The historical fantasy setting Common criticisms: - Pacing drags between major plot points - Romance feels rushed/underdeveloped - Some found the ending unsatisfying - Fantasy elements need more explanation - Character motivations can feel unclear Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (11,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (1,800+ reviews) Barnes & Noble: 4.3/5 (40+ reviews) One frequent comment from positive reviews: "A fresh take on fairy tales with heart." Critical reviews often note: "Beautiful writing but moves too slowly in places." The book won Amazon's Breakthrough Novel Award in 2014.

The Near Witch by Victoria Schwab A tale of magic and folklore follows an orphaned girl in a remote village who searches for missing children with the help of a mysterious stranger.

The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender by Leslye Walton Generations of women face love and loss in a magical realism story centered on a girl born with wings in the Pacific Northwest.

The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill A young witch raises a moon-fed baby with magical powers while protecting her from those who fear magic in their midst.

The House of Salt and Sorrows by Erin A. Craig Twelve sisters live in a manor by the sea, where they confront ancient gods and dark magic as they investigate their siblings' deaths.

The Bone Garden by Heather Kassner A girl made from bone dust and magic seeks her place in the world while uncovering truths about her creator and herself.

🌟 The book won Amazon's 2014 Breakthrough Novel Award in the Young Adult Fiction category. 🌊 Author Carrie Anne Noble was inspired to write the story after having a vivid dream about a girl whose sister was turning into a mermaid. 🏰 The story takes place in a magical version of Pennsylvania's Pocono Mountains in the late 1800s. 🌿 The tale incorporates elements of medieval herbalism and folk medicine, reflecting the main character's training as an apprentice healer. 🐉 Noble intentionally blended multiple fairy tale elements, including mermaids, dragons, and wyverns, to create a unique fantasy world that exists alongside the historical setting.