📖 Overview
Red-Tails in Love chronicles the story of wild red-tailed hawks in New York City's Central Park, centering on a mating pair that attempts to nest on a building overlooking Fifth Avenue. The book follows birdwatchers, or "hawkwatchers," who observe and document the hawks' activities through changing seasons.
Author Marie Winn interweaves the hawks' story with observations of Central Park's wider ecosystem and the community of nature enthusiasts who gather there daily. The narrative captures the intersection of urban and natural worlds, documenting how wild creatures adapt to life in America's most populous city.
The book presents a multi-layered exploration of nature, community, and survival in an urban environment. Through the parallel stories of hawks and humans, Winn examines how wilderness persists within city limits and how observers become deeply invested in the lives of wild creatures.
👀 Reviews
Readers appreciate Winn's ability to weave multiple nature storylines beyond just the hawks, including detailed observations of other Central Park wildlife. Many note how the book captures the community of birders and their dedication to monitoring the hawks. Several reviews mention the book reads like a novel despite being non-fiction.
Common criticisms focus on the pacing in the middle sections and what some readers call "excessive" detail about individual birders' personal lives. A few reviews note confusion about the timeline of events.
"The perfect mix of science and storytelling" appears in multiple reader reviews. "Too much focus on the human observers instead of the birds themselves" is a frequent critique.
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (1,100+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.4/5 (130+ ratings)
LibraryThing: 3.8/5 (300+ ratings)
Most recommend it for urban nature enthusiasts and casual birders rather than serious ornithologists or academic readers.
📚 Similar books
The Wild Parrots of Telegraph Hill by Mark Bittner
The narrative follows a flock of wild parrots and their human observers in San Francisco, blending nature study with urban life.
Wesley the Owl by Stacey O'Brien A biologist's account documents her 19-year relationship with an injured barn owl, revealing insights into owl behavior and the connection between humans and wild creatures.
Providence of a Sparrow by Chris Chester The chronicles of a house sparrow's life with his human caretaker presents bird behavior observations and life in Portland, Oregon.
Mind of the Raven by Bernd Heinrich A naturalist's research combines scientific observation with personal experience to uncover the complex social lives and behaviors of ravens.
The Urban Bestiary by Lyanda Lynn Haupt The exploration of wildlife in cities follows different species adapting to urban environments, with particular focus on birds and their interactions with human observers.
Wesley the Owl by Stacey O'Brien A biologist's account documents her 19-year relationship with an injured barn owl, revealing insights into owl behavior and the connection between humans and wild creatures.
Providence of a Sparrow by Chris Chester The chronicles of a house sparrow's life with his human caretaker presents bird behavior observations and life in Portland, Oregon.
Mind of the Raven by Bernd Heinrich A naturalist's research combines scientific observation with personal experience to uncover the complex social lives and behaviors of ravens.
The Urban Bestiary by Lyanda Lynn Haupt The exploration of wildlife in cities follows different species adapting to urban environments, with particular focus on birds and their interactions with human observers.
🤔 Interesting facts
🦅 Unlike most red-tailed hawks who build nests in tall trees, Pale Male (the book's main hawk) chose to nest on a Manhattan building ledge, pioneering urban hawk nesting behavior.
📚 Author Marie Winn originally chronicled Pale Male's story through her nature column in The Wall Street Journal before expanding it into this book.
🌿 Central Park, where much of the story takes place, contains over 26,000 trees, making it an unexpected but thriving urban ecosystem for wildlife.
🔭 The book showcases a dedicated group of bird watchers known as "the regulars," who maintained detailed daily logs of hawk activities for over a decade.
🦊 The story of the red-tailed hawks coincided with another remarkable Central Park wildlife event - the appearance of an Eastern coyote in 1999, the first seen in Manhattan since the 1600s.