📖 Overview
A Play of Heresy follows Joliffe, a former player turned spy, as he investigates religious tensions in 15th century England. His superior sends him to assist a bishop's inquiry into potential Lollard heretics in the town of Coventry.
Joliffe must navigate complex local politics while posing as a player in a religious pageant for Corpus Christi Day. The town's merchants, clergy, and common folk all harbor secrets, and distinguishing true heresy from personal grudges proves challenging.
The narrative combines medieval theater, religious conflict, and political intrigue against the backdrop of pre-Reformation England. The story moves between rehearsal spaces, taverns, private homes, and churches as Joliffe works to uncover the truth.
The book examines questions of faith, loyalty, and the power of both religious and secular authorities in medieval society. Through its historical setting, it explores themes that remain relevant to modern discussions of belief and persecution.
👀 Reviews
Readers call this medieval mystery a solid addition to the Joliffe series, appreciating the historical details and religious politics of 1437 England. Multiple reviews note the book works well as a standalone, even for those unfamiliar with previous entries.
Readers liked:
- Authentic period dialogue and customs
- Complex religious debate woven into the mystery
- Development of Joliffe's character
- Historical accuracy about Lollardy movement
Common criticisms:
- Slower pacing than other books in series
- Religious discussions overshadow the mystery elements
- Some found the politics confusing without prior knowledge
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.09/5 (273 ratings)
Amazon: 4.4/5 (41 ratings)
"The historical and religious detail makes the story come alive," notes one Amazon reviewer. A Goodreads review states: "The mystery takes a backseat to the theological debates, which may disappoint some readers."
📚 Similar books
The Apothecary Rose by Candace Robb
A medieval monk investigates murders in 14th century York while navigating church politics and local tensions.
The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco A Franciscan friar and his novice solve a series of murders at a Benedictine monastery in 14th century Italy while confronting religious controversies.
Wine of Violence by Priscilla Royal A young prioress takes charge of a priory in 13th century England and uncovers murder plots within the religious community.
The Novice's Tale by Margaret Frazer Dame Frevisse investigates the death of a young nun in a medieval English priory while dealing with internal monastery conflicts.
The Crown in Darkness by P.C. Doherty A medieval scholar solves murders in 14th century Scotland while uncovering plots against the crown and church.
The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco A Franciscan friar and his novice solve a series of murders at a Benedictine monastery in 14th century Italy while confronting religious controversies.
Wine of Violence by Priscilla Royal A young prioress takes charge of a priory in 13th century England and uncovers murder plots within the religious community.
The Novice's Tale by Margaret Frazer Dame Frevisse investigates the death of a young nun in a medieval English priory while dealing with internal monastery conflicts.
The Crown in Darkness by P.C. Doherty A medieval scholar solves murders in 14th century Scotland while uncovering plots against the crown and church.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎭 "A Play of Heresy" is the 17th book in Margaret Frazer's Dame Frevisse medieval mystery series, which she wrote while battling cancer.
📚 The novel explores the controversial Lollard movement, a pre-Protestant Christian sect that challenged Catholic Church authority and advocated for Bible translation into English.
⚔️ The book's 1437 setting coincides with a period of growing tension between religious authorities and reformers, just decades before the Wars of the Roses would begin in England.
🎪 Medieval traveling players, featured prominently in the story, were often viewed with suspicion by church authorities, as their performances could spread "dangerous" ideas to common people.
✒️ Margaret Frazer, whose real name was Gail Frazer, collaborated with Mary Monica Pulver on the early Dame Frevisse books before writing the series solo from the seventh book onward.