Book
A Secret Sisterhood: The Literary Friendships of Jane Austen, Charlotte Brontë, George Eliot, and Virginia Woolf
by Emily Midorikawa, Emma Claire Sweeney
📖 Overview
A Secret Sisterhood uncovers the hidden friendships between four iconic women writers of English literature. The book draws from letters, diaries, and manuscripts to reconstruct relationships that history has overlooked.
The authors explore Jane Austen's bond with amateur playwright Anne Sharp, Charlotte Brontë's connection to feminist writer Mary Taylor, George Eliot's friendship with Harriet Beecher Stowe, and Virginia Woolf's relationship with Katherine Mansfield. Through extensive research, they reveal how these relationships influenced the writers' work and lives.
The text includes new discoveries from archives and family collections, presenting evidence that challenges the common perception of these authors as isolated artists. Margaret Atwood contributes the foreword, adding context about female literary relationships.
This work speaks to broader themes about women's artistic partnerships and why certain narratives persist while others fade from historical record. The authors make a case for reconsidering how creative influence and literary support networks operated in past centuries.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this book reveals lesser-known friendships between female authors but falls short of its premise. Many appreciate the new research and historical context about literary women supporting each other, particularly the sections on Jane Austen and Charlotte Brontë.
Likes:
- Fills gaps in literary history
- Well-researched primary sources
- Challenges the "isolated genius" narrative
- Strong chapter on Harriet Beecher Stowe and George Eliot
Dislikes:
- Writing style described as dry and academic
- Too much speculation and "might have" statements
- Uneven coverage of the friendships
- Some readers wanted more direct quotes from letters
- Virginia Woolf section feels rushed
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (2,100+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.0/5 (120+ ratings)
Several reviewers mention the book works better as an academic reference than a narrative read. Multiple readers note it provides good historical background but doesn't fully capture the intimacy of the friendships it describes.
📚 Similar books
A Room of Their Own by Daisy Goodwin and Emma Soames
A biographical examination of the connections between female writers, artists, and intellectuals in the Bloomsbury Group through letters, diaries, and personal accounts.
Literary Witches by Taisia Kitaiskaia Portraits of 30 women writers throughout history reveal their connections, influences, and shared experiences as creative pioneers.
The Republic of Letters by Marc Fumaroli A study of correspondence networks between writers, philosophers, and intellectuals in the 18th and 19th centuries illuminates their private friendships and professional alliances.
Between Women by Sharon Marcus An analysis of female relationships in Victorian England explores how women's friendships shaped literature and society.
Writing with Jane Austen by Anne Sharp A deep dive into Jane Austen's creative process through her relationships with fellow women writers and confidantes reveals the collaborative nature of literary creation in the Georgian era.
Literary Witches by Taisia Kitaiskaia Portraits of 30 women writers throughout history reveal their connections, influences, and shared experiences as creative pioneers.
The Republic of Letters by Marc Fumaroli A study of correspondence networks between writers, philosophers, and intellectuals in the 18th and 19th centuries illuminates their private friendships and professional alliances.
Between Women by Sharon Marcus An analysis of female relationships in Victorian England explores how women's friendships shaped literature and society.
Writing with Jane Austen by Anne Sharp A deep dive into Jane Austen's creative process through her relationships with fellow women writers and confidantes reveals the collaborative nature of literary creation in the Georgian era.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Emily Midorikawa and Emma Claire Sweeney were themselves friends and writing partners before collaborating on this book, mirroring the literary friendships they explored.
📚 The book reveals that Jane Austen maintained a significant friendship with amateur playwright Anne Sharp, who worked as a governess at Austen's wealthy brother's estate.
✍️ Margaret George Eliot's close friend Harriet Beecher Stowe (author of Uncle Tom's Cabin) never met in person, but maintained a deep friendship through letters exchanged across the Atlantic.
📝 Virginia Woolf's friendship with Katherine Mansfield was complex and competitive, yet Woolf considered Mansfield the only writer whose opinion she truly valued.
🎯 The book challenges the long-held notion that these famous female authors were lonely geniuses who worked in isolation, revealing instead a network of supportive literary friendships that helped shape their work.