Directorate S

Directorate S examines America's intelligence and military operations in Afghanistan and Pakistan from 2001-2016. The book focuses on the complex relationship between the CIA, ISI (Pakistan's intelligence service), and Afghanistan's various power players in the post-9/11 era. The narrative tracks key figures in the American military and intelligence community as they attempt to navigate Pakistan's deep involvement in Afghanistan through ISI's "Directorate S" division. Steve Coll draws on extensive interviews and documents to reconstruct the decisions, miscalculations, and competing agendas that shaped U.S. policy in the region. Multiple perspectives emerge through accounts from CIA operatives, Pakistani intelligence officers, Afghan leaders, and U.S. military commanders. The book documents their attempts to achieve often conflicting objectives while dealing with shifting alliances and hidden motivations. The work reveals how institutional blind spots and misaligned incentives can undermine even well-resourced foreign policy initiatives. Through its examination of the Afghanistan-Pakistan theater, the book raises fundamental questions about the limits of American power and intelligence capabilities in foreign conflicts.

Readers praise the depth of research and detailed accounts of key intelligence operations in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Many note the book provides context missing from news coverage, with one reader calling it "the clearest explanation of why the US struggled to achieve its goals in Afghanistan." Positive comments focus on: - Clear explanation of complex relationships between ISI, CIA, and Taliban - Balanced portrayal of multiple perspectives - Documentation of previously unreported events Common criticisms: - Length and density make it challenging to follow - Too many characters and organizations to track - Some readers found the chronological jumps confusing Several readers mention needing to take notes or refer back to earlier chapters to keep details straight. Ratings: Goodreads: 4.37/5 (2,900+ ratings) Amazon: 4.6/5 (1,100+ ratings) Kirkus Reviews: Starred review Washington Post readers' average: 4.5/5 Most negative reviews still praise the reporting but cite readability issues.

Ghost Wars by Steve Coll A chronicle of the CIA's involvement in Afghanistan from the Soviet invasion through September 10, 2001.

The Looming Tower by Lawrence Wright The narrative tracks Al-Qaeda's path to 9/11 through the intersecting lives of key figures in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and America.

The Great War for Civilisation by Robert Fisk A front-line reporter's account of conflicts in Afghanistan, Iraq, and other Middle Eastern countries from the 1970s through the post-9/11 period.

Little America by Rajiv Chandrasekaran An examination of the U.S. military's efforts in southern Afghanistan and the strategic decisions that shaped America's longest war.

Taliban by Ahmed Rashid A detailed history of the Taliban's rise to power in Afghanistan and their relationship with Al-Qaeda, Pakistan's ISI, and international actors.

🔹 During his research for Directorate S, Steve Coll conducted over 550 interviews across multiple countries, including speaking with CIA officers, ISI officials, and Afghan intelligence personnel. 🔹 The book's title refers to the secret unit within Pakistan's ISI intelligence agency that was specifically tasked with supporting the Taliban, even while Pakistan was officially an American ally. 🔹 Steve Coll won his second Pulitzer Prize for his previous book about Afghanistan, Ghost Wars, which serves as a prequel to Directorate S and covers the period from 1979 to 2001. 🔹 The book reveals that Pakistan's nuclear weapons program significantly influenced U.S. policy in the region, as American officials feared pushing Pakistan too hard on Taliban support could destabilize control of their nuclear arsenal. 🔹 Many of the book's revelations about CIA operations came from the personal diary of Ambassador Richard Holbrooke, who served as Obama's special representative to Afghanistan and Pakistan until his death in 2010.