The Rise and Fall of English

The Rise and Fall of English examines the state of English studies and humanities education in American universities during the late 20th century. Through analysis of curriculum changes and pedagogical approaches, Robert Scholes traces how English departments evolved from their origins to their current form. Scholes draws on his decades of experience as a professor and scholar to discuss the forces shaping literary studies, composition, and rhetoric programs. He presents case studies from various institutions while exploring the broader cultural and institutional factors influencing how English is taught and studied. The book addresses practical questions about reading, writing, and textual interpretation while engaging with theoretical debates in the field. Scholes considers the role of English departments in relation to other academic disciplines and the wider goals of liberal education. At its core, this work confronts fundamental questions about the purpose of studying literature and language in an era of changing educational priorities. The analysis points to possible future directions for English studies while examining what may be gained or lost as the discipline continues to evolve.

Readers find the book makes a compelling case for reforming English education, though some view the suggested changes as too radical. Teachers and professors report the text helped them rethink their approach to literature instruction. Liked: - Clear analysis of historical shifts in English education - Practical suggestions for teaching media literacy - Strong arguments for moving beyond New Criticism - Accessible writing style for academic text Disliked: - Limited concrete examples of proposed teaching methods - Some repetitive sections - Too focused on college-level teaching vs. K-12 - Arguments against traditional literary analysis seen as oversimplified Ratings: Goodreads: 3.8/5 (42 ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (12 ratings) "Changed how I approach teaching literature," noted one professor reviewer on Goodreads. A high school teacher on Amazon called it "theoretical without being practical enough for classroom use." Limited review data exists online as the book targets an academic audience.

The Death and Life of the Great American School System by Diane Ravitch This examination of education reform movements traces the impact of standardized testing and market-based policies on literacy education in America.

Teaching Literature by Elaine Showalter The book presents methods for teaching literature in higher education while exploring the evolution of English studies as a discipline.

The Language Police by Diane Ravitch This investigation reveals how textbook publishing and educational policies shape the teaching of reading and writing in schools.

What's Liberal About the Liberal Arts? by Michael Bérubé The text analyzes the role of humanities education in contemporary society while addressing critiques of English departments and liberal arts instruction.

Literature Lost by John M. Ellis This critique examines the transformation of literary studies in American universities and its effects on student learning.

🔖 Robert Scholes was a pioneering figure in literary theory and semiotics, teaching at Brown University for over 30 years. 📚 The book challenges traditional methods of teaching English literature, suggesting a shift from pure interpretation to "textual power" - the ability to analyze, consume, and produce various types of texts. 📖 Published in 1998, the book came at a crucial time when English departments were grappling with changing technology and evolving student needs in the digital age. ✍️ Scholes advocates for teaching "protocols of reading" rather than just canonical texts, emphasizing skills that help students engage with all forms of communication. 🎓 The author draws from his extensive experience in both high school and university teaching, providing practical examples of how English education can be reformed to better serve modern students.