📖 Overview
Nicholas Lemann's Redemption chronicles the violent resistance to Reconstruction in Mississippi during 1873-1875. The book centers on events in Vicksburg and the actions of White Line paramilitary groups who sought to overturn Republican rule and black voting rights.
The narrative follows key figures including former Confederate general James George, Mississippi governor Adelbert Ames, and African American political leader James Hill. Through primary sources and period documentation, Lemann reconstructs the strategies, conflicts and political maneuvering that characterized this pivotal period.
Terror campaigns, murders, and voter intimidation marked the Democrats' efforts to regain control of Mississippi's state government. The federal government's response and eventual withdrawal of support for Reconstruction efforts forms a crucial part of the historical account.
The book reveals how this brief period shaped race relations and power structures in the American South for generations to come. Lemann's work highlights enduring questions about democracy, citizenship rights, and the use of violence as a political tool.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this focused historical account sheds light on the violent suppression of Black voting rights in Mississippi during Reconstruction. Many reviewers appreciate Lemann's detailed research and clear presentation of a lesser-known period after the Civil War.
Readers praised:
- Clear explanation of complex political maneuvering
- Documentation of primary sources and testimonies
- Connection to modern voting rights issues
- Tight focus on events in Mississippi
Common criticisms:
- Narrow geographic scope limited to one state
- Some passages get bogged down in minor details
- Limited coverage of broader Reconstruction context
- Writing style can feel dry and academic
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (378 ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (86 ratings)
Several reviewers noted the book reads "more like a lengthy newspaper article than a narrative history." Multiple readers mentioned they had not previously known about these events despite being well-versed in Civil War history.
📚 Similar books
The Day Freedom Died by Charles Lane
The story of the 1873 Colfax Massacre in Louisiana reveals the violent resistance to Reconstruction and the federal government's struggle to protect Black citizens' rights.
Stony the Road by Henry Louis Gates Jr. A detailed examination of the rollback of Reconstruction's promises through the rise of Jim Crow laws and white supremacist terrorism between 1877 and 1915.
The Republic for Which It Stands by Richard White This examination of the post-Civil War United States traces the nation's transformation through Reconstruction and the Gilded Age, with focus on racial violence and political compromises.
Forever Free by Eric Foner The collapse of Reconstruction and its aftermath unfolds through the experiences of both Black and white Americans as the promise of civil rights eroded in the South.
The Bloody Shirt by Stephen Budiansky The experiences of five men in the post-Civil War South illustrate the organized campaign of terrorism against Reconstruction through primary sources and historical documentation.
Stony the Road by Henry Louis Gates Jr. A detailed examination of the rollback of Reconstruction's promises through the rise of Jim Crow laws and white supremacist terrorism between 1877 and 1915.
The Republic for Which It Stands by Richard White This examination of the post-Civil War United States traces the nation's transformation through Reconstruction and the Gilded Age, with focus on racial violence and political compromises.
Forever Free by Eric Foner The collapse of Reconstruction and its aftermath unfolds through the experiences of both Black and white Americans as the promise of civil rights eroded in the South.
The Bloody Shirt by Stephen Budiansky The experiences of five men in the post-Civil War South illustrate the organized campaign of terrorism against Reconstruction through primary sources and historical documentation.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Author Nicholas Lemann is the Dean Emeritus of Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism and has written for The New Yorker since 1999.
🔹 The book details the violent campaign waged by white Southerners against Black citizens and their white Republican allies in Mississippi during the Reconstruction era, particularly focusing on the massacre in Colfax, Louisiana in 1873.
🔹 President Ulysses S. Grant, who features prominently in the book, sent federal troops to Mississippi in 1875 to protect Black voters, marking one of the last major federal interventions in Southern politics during Reconstruction.
🔹 The events chronicled in "Redemption" helped establish the Jim Crow system that would dominate the South for nearly a century, effectively nullifying the 14th and 15th Amendments until the Civil Rights Movement.
🔹 The term "Redemption" was used by white Southerners to describe their campaign to retake control of state governments from the Reconstruction coalition of Republicans, freedmen, and carpetbaggers.