📖 Overview
So This Is Permanence presents Ian Curtis's lyrics and personal notebooks, offering direct access to the Joy Division frontman's creative process and inner thoughts. The collection includes reproductions of original handwritten pages alongside typed transcriptions.
The book contains Curtis's complete lyrics for Joy Division songs, both released and unreleased, along with fragments of unfinished works. Personal notes, lists, and diary entries provide context around the band's development and Curtis's songwriting methods.
Deborah Curtis, Ian's widow, provides commentary and background information throughout the volume. The book includes photographs and images of memorabilia that have not previously been published.
This compilation reveals recurring motifs of isolation, disconnection, and internal struggle that defined both Curtis's writing and Joy Division's musical identity. The raw materials collected here illuminate the intersection between personal experience and artistic expression.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this collection as a raw glimpse into Ian Curtis's creative process through his handwritten lyrics, notes and personal writings. Many note the high production quality of the physical book and clarity of the manuscript reproductions.
Positives from reviews:
- Detailed annotations provide context for each piece
- Shows evolution of lyrics through multiple drafts
- Includes previously unpublished material
- High quality paper and binding
- Clear photos of original notebooks
Common criticisms:
- Price point too high for some readers
- Some found Deborah Curtis's introduction too brief
- A few mention wanting more analysis/commentary
Ratings across platforms:
Goodreads: 4.44/5 (250+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.7/5 (100+ reviews)
Notable reader comment from Goodreads: "The reproductions are incredible - you can see every crossed out word and margin note. It's like looking over Ian's shoulder as he writes."
📚 Similar books
Unknown Pleasures: Inside Joy Division by Peter Hook
The bassist of Joy Division presents his personal archives, photographs, and detailed accounts of the band's creative process and Ian Curtis's songwriting methods.
Love Will Tear Us Apart: The Life of Ian Curtis by Mick Middles, Lindsay Reade This biography draws from personal documents and interviews with Curtis's family to reveal the mechanics behind his lyrics and creative process.
Touching From a Distance by Deborah Curtis Ian Curtis's widow presents her husband's letters, notebooks, and personal effects while documenting his evolution as a writer and musician.
This Searing Light, The Sun and Everything Else: Joy Division by Jon Savage The book compiles oral histories from band members, associates, and contemporaries to construct a timeline of Joy Division's creative development and Curtis's songwriting journey.
Torn Apart: The Life of Ian Curtis by Mick Middles, Lindsay Reade The authors examine Curtis's personal journals, letters, and writing process through interviews with those who witnessed his creative development.
Love Will Tear Us Apart: The Life of Ian Curtis by Mick Middles, Lindsay Reade This biography draws from personal documents and interviews with Curtis's family to reveal the mechanics behind his lyrics and creative process.
Touching From a Distance by Deborah Curtis Ian Curtis's widow presents her husband's letters, notebooks, and personal effects while documenting his evolution as a writer and musician.
This Searing Light, The Sun and Everything Else: Joy Division by Jon Savage The book compiles oral histories from band members, associates, and contemporaries to construct a timeline of Joy Division's creative development and Curtis's songwriting journey.
Torn Apart: The Life of Ian Curtis by Mick Middles, Lindsay Reade The authors examine Curtis's personal journals, letters, and writing process through interviews with those who witnessed his creative development.
🤔 Interesting facts
📖 The handwritten notebooks featured in the book were kept private by Ian Curtis's widow, Deborah, for over 30 years before being published.
🎼 Many of the lyrics shown in the book differ significantly from the final recorded versions of Joy Division songs, offering insight into Curtis's creative process.
✍️ The book includes previously unseen photographs of Curtis's original handwritten lyrics, complete with his crossed-out words and margin notes.
🎸 Several of the notebooks contain Curtis's detailed plans for Joy Division's live performances, including stage layouts and equipment arrangements.
📚 The collection reveals Curtis's deep interest in literature, with references to writers like William S. Burroughs, J.G. Ballard, and Franz Kafka scattered throughout his personal notes.