Supreme Command: Soldiers, Statesmen, and Leadership in Wartime

Supreme Command examines the wartime leadership of four democratic statesmen: Abraham Lincoln, Georges Clemenceau, Winston Churchill, and David Ben-Gurion. Through detailed historical analysis, Cohen explores how these civilian leaders managed their military commanders and directed strategy during periods of conflict. The book challenges conventional wisdom about civil-military relations, particularly the notion that political leaders should establish objectives but leave military operations to the generals. Through case studies spanning multiple wars and countries, Cohen demonstrates how successful wartime leaders maintained active, detailed involvement in military planning and decision-making. The work draws on primary sources, military documents, and personal correspondence to reconstruct the complex dynamics between these leaders and their generals. Cohen provides context about each leader's background and the specific challenges they faced during their respective conflicts. Supreme Command presents a thesis about democratic leadership during war that remains relevant to modern civil-military relations and strategic decision-making. The book's analysis of how civilian control can be effectively exercised over military institutions offers insights for contemporary political and military leaders.

Readers value Cohen's analysis of how civilian leaders like Lincoln and Churchill successfully managed military operations and challenged their generals' recommendations. Many reviewers highlight the book's relevance for understanding civilian-military relations and decision-making during wartime. Positives: - Clear historical examples that support the central thesis - Strong scholarship and research - Practical lessons for modern leadership - Accessible writing style for non-military readers Negatives: - Some readers found it repetitive - A few reviewers felt it oversimplified complex military decisions - Critics note it focuses mainly on successful wartime leaders rather than failed ones Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (376 ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (116 ratings) One military officer reviewer noted: "Cohen effectively demonstrates why civilian control of the military is essential through compelling historical case studies." A critical review stated: "The book would benefit from examining cases where civilian micromanagement led to failure."

War and Politics by Bernard Brodie A study of civil-military relations through history that examines how political leadership shapes military strategy and operations.

The Mask of Command by John Keegan An analysis of military leadership through the examination of four commanders - Alexander, Wellington, Grant, and Hitler - and their relationship with political power.

On War by Carl von Clausewitz The foundational text on the relationship between political objectives and military means demonstrates how warfare serves political ends.

Military Strategy: A General Theory of Power Control by J.C. Wylie A theoretical framework for understanding how civilian leaders and military commanders interact in the development of strategy.

The Soldiers and the State by Samuel P. Huntington An examination of the theory of civil-military relations and the concept of objective civilian control over military forces.

🎯 Cohen wrote this book partly in response to the "normal theory of civil-military relations," which suggests civilian leaders should set broad goals but leave military decisions to generals 🏛️ The book examines four wartime leaders - Lincoln, Clemenceau, Churchill, and Ben-Gurion - who all took unusually active roles in military strategy despite lacking formal military training 📚 The author served as Counselor to the U.S. Department of State under Condoleezza Rice and used his observations of modern civil-military relations to inform his historical analysis ⚔️ The book challenges the popular "hands-off" leadership model promoted by Secretary of Defense Caspar Weinberger and Colin Powell, known as the Weinberger-Powell Doctrine 🎓 Cohen wrote this influential work while serving as a professor at Johns Hopkins University's School of Advanced International Studies, where it became required reading in many military education programs