War! What Is It Good For?

War! What Is It Good For? examines the paradoxical role of organized violence in human civilization over 15,000 years. Morris argues that warfare has driven the creation of larger, more complex societies and ultimately reduced rates of violent death. The book traces humanity's development from hunter-gatherer groups through early states and empires to the modern era. Through archaeological evidence and historical analysis, Morris explores how different forms of warfare shaped government structures and social organization across cultures and continents. Morris investigates key periods of military innovation and their impacts on human development, from ancient Rome to medieval China to the nuclear age. The text draws on anthropology, archaeology, history, and political science to build its central case. This work challenges conventional views about warfare's effects on human progress and presents a perspective on how organized violence has shaped the modern world order. The book raises questions about the nature of peace, governance, and what the future may hold for human conflict.

Readers view this book as a provocative argument that war has made humanity safer and more prosperous over time. The thesis generates strong reactions in reviews. Readers appreciate: - Clear writing style and engaging historical examples - Thorough research and data to support claims - Fresh perspective on war's role in state-building - Integration of archaeology and anthropology Common criticisms: - Oversimplifies complex historical events - Insufficient attention to war's human costs - Too focused on Western/European history - Some readers find the core argument morally troubling Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (766 ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (156 ratings) Sample reader comments: "Makes you think differently about conflict but glosses over too much" - Goodreads reviewer "Well-researched but ethically concerning" - Amazon reviewer "Strong on data, weak on acknowledging suffering" - LibraryThing review Several academic reviewers note the book presents an important but incomplete view of war's societal impacts.

Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond This book examines how geography and environmental factors shaped human societies and warfare throughout history.

The Better Angels of Our Nature by Steven Pinker The book presents data and historical analysis to demonstrate how violence has declined across human civilization.

War and Peace and War by Peter Turchin The text uses mathematical models and historical patterns to explain the rise and fall of empires through cycles of warfare and social cohesion.

Against the Grain by James C. Scott This work explores how early warfare and state formation were linked to the development of agriculture and first civilizations.

The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers by Paul Kennedy The book traces the connection between economic resources, military power, and the fate of major world powers from 1500 to modern times.

🔹 Despite arguing that war has made humanity safer over time, author Ian Morris emphasizes he is not pro-war, stating that nuclear weapons have made war between great powers too dangerous to serve its historical "productive" function. 🔹 The book's title was inspired by the 1970 Edwin Starr song "War (What Is It Good For?)," though Morris reaches a very different conclusion than the song's famous "absolutely nothing" answer. 🔹 Morris calculates that Stone Age humans faced a 10-20% chance of dying violently, while today's odds are less than 1% - largely due to the state-building processes that warfare enabled. 🔹 The author suggests that the ancient Roman Empire reduced violence so effectively that it wasn't until the 20th century that European society became equally peaceful, despite the World Wars. 🔹 Morris's research shows that successful ancient empires typically reduced violent death rates by 95% within their borders compared to pre-state societies, though they often achieved this through brutal initial conquests.