📖 Overview
11 Experiments That Failed follows a young girl who conducts a series of unconventional science experiments. Each experiment begins with a question, lists required materials and a hypothesis, then documents the results.
The experiments range from testing if humans can survive on snow and ketchup to investigating whether pets enjoy being dressed in suits of armor. Through documented observations and photographs, readers watch as the protagonist's experiments lead to unexpected outcomes.
Through humor and hands-on investigation, the book celebrates scientific curiosity while gently demonstrating the value of trial and error. The story captures a child's natural inclination to test boundaries and ask "what if?" - even when the questions seem absurd to adults.
👀 Reviews
Readers praise this children's book for making science fun through silly experiments like "Can a kid make it through the winter eating only snow and ketchup?" Parents and teachers note it helps introduce the scientific method in an engaging way that appeals to elementary students.
Liked:
- Humorous illustrations that complement the text
- Clear experiment setup, hypothesis, and results format
- Encourages critical thinking while being entertaining
- Works well as a read-aloud book
Disliked:
- Some parents worry it might give children unsafe ideas
- A few readers found the experiments too absurd
- Higher price point for a relatively short book
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.15/5 (1,100+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.7/5 (240+ ratings)
Common reader comment: "My students laugh out loud at the ridiculous experiments while learning about hypotheses and scientific observation."
📚 Similar books
Oh No! Not Another Science Experiment! by Paula Green
Children follow the misadventures of a student who conducts backfired experiments at school and home.
Rosie Revere, Engineer by Andrea Beaty A young girl learns from her failed inventions and persists in building new machines.
Charlotte the Scientist Is Squished by Camille Andros A rabbit scientist uses the scientific method to solve her space problem through multiple attempts.
The Most Magnificent Thing by Ashley Spires A girl and her dog assistant work through numerous failed attempts to create an undefined magnificent invention.
Ada Twist, Scientist by Andrea Beaty A curious child conducts experiments to answer her questions about the world, leading to messy results and new discoveries.
Rosie Revere, Engineer by Andrea Beaty A young girl learns from her failed inventions and persists in building new machines.
Charlotte the Scientist Is Squished by Camille Andros A rabbit scientist uses the scientific method to solve her space problem through multiple attempts.
The Most Magnificent Thing by Ashley Spires A girl and her dog assistant work through numerous failed attempts to create an undefined magnificent invention.
Ada Twist, Scientist by Andrea Beaty A curious child conducts experiments to answer her questions about the world, leading to messy results and new discoveries.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔬 Author Jenny Offill took inspiration from real childhood science experiments, including some she attempted herself as a kid.
📚 The book's illustrator, Nancy Carpenter, used a combination of mixed media techniques including photography, drawing, and digital manipulation to create the distinctive visual style.
🧪 The experiments in the book follow the actual scientific method format, complete with hypotheses, materials lists, and results—teaching young readers real scientific principles through humor.
🏆 The book received a Kirkus starred review and was named one of School Library Journal's Best Books of 2011.
🎨 The book's unique visual presentation includes "notes" that appear to be written on graph paper, brown paper bags, and other household items, creating an authentic "kid scientist" feel.