📖 Overview
After a humiliating loss to her ex-girlfriend's basketball team, high school senior Scottie gets into a minor car accident with her nemesis - cheerleading captain Irene. Their insurance battle leads to an unexpected carpooling arrangement that forces them to spend time together each morning.
The fake dating trope takes center stage when Scottie realizes she can use Irene's popularity to get revenge on her ex. Their arrangement evolves beyond simple revenge as they navigate high school social dynamics, sports rivalries, and their growing connection.
The story tracks Scottie and Irene's relationship against the backdrop of competitive high school basketball and cheerleading. Their individual growth intertwines with team dynamics and the complexities of being out in high school.
Through its romantic comedy framework, this YA novel examines themes of pride, vulnerability, and the courage to move past first impressions. The narrative explores how revenge plots and defense mechanisms can unexpectedly lead to authentic connections.
👀 Reviews
Readers frequently mention the book's humor, witty banter, and authentic portrayal of high school sports dynamics. Many note the enemies-to-lovers romance develops at a natural pace and appreciate the representation of LGBTQ+ teens in a light-hearted story.
What readers liked:
- Chemistry between main characters
- Sports team dynamics and basketball scenes
- Family relationships, especially sibling dynamics
- Comic relief characters
- Small-town setting details
What readers disliked:
- Some found the fake dating trope predictable
- Initial chapters move slowly
- Side characters could use more development
- A few readers wanted more emotional depth
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.0/5 (28,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.5/5 (1,100+ ratings)
BookTok: Frequently recommended in #sapphicbooks tags
Common reader comment: "Perfect blend of sports, humor, and romance without getting too heavy" - multiple Goodreads reviews
📚 Similar books
Hani and Ishu's Guide to Fake Dating by Adiba Jaigirdar
Two girls enter a fake dating arrangement at their Irish Catholic school to boost one's popularity and help the other become head girl.
One True Loves by Elise Bryant A romance-skeptic high school senior finds herself caught between two potential loves while on a European cruise with her family.
Perfect on Paper by Sophie Gonzales A bisexual teen who runs an anonymous relationship advice service at her school faces her own romantic complications when she falls for the person who discovered her secret.
Some Girls Do by Jennifer Dugan A track star who was forced to transfer schools after coming out meets a closeted beauty queen, leading to a secret romance that challenges both their identities.
Cool for the Summer by Dahlia Adler A high school senior must confront her feelings when her long-time male crush finally notices her just as the girl she spent the summer with transfers to her school.
One True Loves by Elise Bryant A romance-skeptic high school senior finds herself caught between two potential loves while on a European cruise with her family.
Perfect on Paper by Sophie Gonzales A bisexual teen who runs an anonymous relationship advice service at her school faces her own romantic complications when she falls for the person who discovered her secret.
Some Girls Do by Jennifer Dugan A track star who was forced to transfer schools after coming out meets a closeted beauty queen, leading to a secret romance that challenges both their identities.
Cool for the Summer by Dahlia Adler A high school senior must confront her feelings when her long-time male crush finally notices her just as the girl she spent the summer with transfers to her school.
🤔 Interesting facts
🏀 The novel authentically portrays competitive high school basketball, drawing from author Kelly Quindlen's own experience playing varsity sports in high school.
📚 This book was named to the ALA Rainbow List 2022, which recognizes quality LGBTQIA+ literature for children and teens.
💕 The fake-dating trope used in the story has roots in classic romantic comedies like "10 Things I Hate About You" and "Drive Me Crazy," with the latter possibly inspiring the book's title.
🎨 The cover art, featuring two girls in letterman jackets, was illustrated by Stephanie Son, known for creating inclusive and diverse book cover illustrations.
🌈 Kelly Quindlen wrote this book as her second LGBTQ+ young adult novel, following her successful debut "Late to the Party," establishing herself as a prominent voice in queer teen literature.