📖 Overview
If They Come for Us is a poetry collection that marks Fatimah Asghar's debut as an author. The book contains poems that span multiple forms and styles, from traditional structures to experimental formats.
The collection explores Asghar's experiences as a Pakistani Muslim orphan growing up in America after 9/11. Through her verses, she documents childhood memories, family dynamics, and the realities of navigating multiple identities in contemporary America.
The poems trace historical events including Partition, examining its impact across generations of South Asian families. Asghar writes about both personal and collective trauma, while also capturing moments of joy, resilience and community.
This collection speaks to themes of belonging, identity formation, and the inheritance of historical memory. The work stands as a testament to how personal narrative intertwines with larger political and social forces.
👀 Reviews
Readers highlight Asghar's raw honesty in exploring identity, grief, and belonging as a queer Pakistani Muslim woman in America. Many cite the poems about family loss and partition history as the collection's strongest elements.
Readers appreciated:
- Innovative formatting and experimental structures
- Powerful handling of trauma without self-pity
- Cultural specificity while maintaining accessibility
- Effective use of Urdu phrases and cultural references
Common criticisms:
- Some poems feel underdeveloped or too abstract
- Inconsistent quality across the collection
- A few readers found certain sections repetitive
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.2/5 (6,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.7/5 (280+ ratings)
Notable reader comments:
"The poems about partition hit like a punch to the gut" - Goodreads reviewer
"Shows the immigrant experience without compromising authenticity" - Amazon reviewer
"Some poems needed more development, but when she hits, she hits hard" - LibraryThing reviewer
📚 Similar books
Night Sky with Exit Wounds by Ocean Vuong
A collection of poems exploring identity, war, and family through the lens of a Vietnamese-American immigrant's experience.
Citizen: An American Lyric by Claudia Rankine A blend of poetry and prose that examines racism and racial aggression in modern American society.
The Wild Fox of Yemen by Threa Almontaser Poems weaving together Muslim and Yemeni-American narratives while navigating cultural boundaries and tradition.
Look by Solmaz Sharif Poetry collection using military terminology to tell stories of war, loss, and Iranian-American identity.
Homie by Danez Smith Poems centered on friendship, identity, and survival as a queer Black person in America.
Citizen: An American Lyric by Claudia Rankine A blend of poetry and prose that examines racism and racial aggression in modern American society.
The Wild Fox of Yemen by Threa Almontaser Poems weaving together Muslim and Yemeni-American narratives while navigating cultural boundaries and tradition.
Look by Solmaz Sharif Poetry collection using military terminology to tell stories of war, loss, and Iranian-American identity.
Homie by Danez Smith Poems centered on friendship, identity, and survival as a queer Black person in America.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Fatimah Asghar wrote much of this poetry collection while working as a writer for the Emmy-nominated web series "Brown Girls"
🌟 The collection explores Asghar's experience as a Pakistani Muslim orphan growing up in America post-9/11
🌟 The title "If They Come for Us" references both historical partition violence in South Asia and contemporary Islamophobia in America
🌟 Asghar experiments with unique poetic forms, including poems structured like crossword puzzles and arcade games
🌟 Many poems in the collection were inspired by old family photographs, though Asghar lost most actual family photos in childhood moves