📖 Overview
A BBC Doctor Who novel featuring the Fourth Doctor, Romana I, and K-9 in a quest that spans centuries and solar systems. The story centers on the ancient god Valdemar, a dark presence who was imprisoned beneath the acid skies of Ashkellia by mysterious entities known as the Old Ones.
The plot follows multiple threads, including novelist Miranda Pelham's research into Valdemar's history and her dangerous alliance with necromancer Paul Neville. The Doctor and his companions become entangled in competing efforts to locate the lost planet of Ashkellia and the tomb of the dark god.
The narrative unfolds in the Palace of the Old Ones, where sulfuric acid clouds and shifting realities create an otherworldly backdrop. The Doctor must choose between his ongoing mission to collect the Key to Time segments and preventing the potential resurrection of Valdemar.
The novel explores themes of power, mythology, and the consequences of uncovering long-buried secrets. It raises questions about the price of knowledge and the responsibilities that come with preserving universal balance.
👀 Reviews
Most readers call this Doctor Who novel slow-paced and confusing, with multiple storylines that don't come together effectively. On review sites, fans note it fails to capture the tone of the TV series.
Readers appreciated:
- The gothic horror atmosphere
- Creative monster concepts
- The standalone nature (no prior Who knowledge needed)
Common criticisms:
- Difficult to follow multiple narratives
- Too many characters introduced
- Slow first half
- Unsatisfying ending
As one Goodreads reviewer noted: "The plot meanders and takes too long to get going. By the time things pick up, it's hard to care about the outcome."
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.2/5 (89 ratings)
Amazon: 2.9/5 (12 ratings)
The book ranks near the bottom of most Doctor Who novel lists and reading guides, with fans recommending other entries in the series instead.
📚 Similar books
House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski
Chronicles a house that defies physics and reality while following multiple narratives and timelines, creating the same sense of cosmic horror and reality-bending exploration found in Tomb of Valdemar.
Necroscope by Brian Lumley Follows a man who can speak with the dead as he uncovers ancient secrets and faces necromancers, matching the Gothic horror and necromantic elements.
The Tomb by F. Paul Wilson Features an ancient evil sealed away and the consequences of its potential awakening, paralleling the imprisoned god concept.
Declare by Tim Powers Combines supernatural entities with espionage across different time periods and locations, sharing the multi-threaded narrative structure and otherworldly threats.
The Book of the Dead by Douglas Preston Centers on an archaeological discovery that unleashes ancient forces, mirroring the themes of dangerous knowledge and ancient powers.
Necroscope by Brian Lumley Follows a man who can speak with the dead as he uncovers ancient secrets and faces necromancers, matching the Gothic horror and necromantic elements.
The Tomb by F. Paul Wilson Features an ancient evil sealed away and the consequences of its potential awakening, paralleling the imprisoned god concept.
Declare by Tim Powers Combines supernatural entities with espionage across different time periods and locations, sharing the multi-threaded narrative structure and otherworldly threats.
The Book of the Dead by Douglas Preston Centers on an archaeological discovery that unleashes ancient forces, mirroring the themes of dangerous knowledge and ancient powers.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔮 The book incorporates elements of the Cthulhu Mythos, sharing similar themes about ancient cosmic entities with H.P. Lovecraft's works.
⏰ It's one of the few Doctor Who novels to extensively utilize multiple timelines as a core narrative device rather than just occasional time travel.
📚 Miranda Pelham, one of the main characters, is named after popular horror novelist Barbara Pym and Mary Shelley, reflecting the book's gothic influences.
🏛️ The Palace of the Old Ones described in the book draws architectural inspiration from both H.P. Lovecraft's R'lyeh and ancient Mesopotamian ziggurats.
🖋️ Author Simon Messingham has written several other Doctor Who novels and scripts, including "The Face-Eater" and "Zeta Major," establishing himself as a regular contributor to the expanded universe.