The Wonder

Lib O'Malley, an English nurse, arrives in rural 1850s Ireland to observe an eleven-year-old girl who claims to have eaten nothing for four months. The girl, Anna O'Donnell, appears healthy despite her fast and has become a local attraction, drawing pilgrim visitors who believe they are witnessing a miracle. As a trained medical professional, Lib approaches her two-week watch duty with skepticism, determined to uncover the truth through careful observation. She must balance her role as an outsider in a deeply Catholic community while maintaining professional distance from her young charge. The story centers on questions of faith versus science, and how different beliefs can shape people's understanding of reality. Through Lib's investigation, long-held certainties begin to shift as she grapples with explaining the inexplicable. The Wonder explores themes of religious fervor, medical ethics, and the complex ways that communities respond to phenomena they cannot explain. The novel raises questions about where truth resides - in observable facts or in matters of faith.

Readers praise Donoghue's meticulous historical research and the gradual building of tension throughout the story. Many note the book effectively explores themes of faith, science, and the complex motivations behind religious fasting. The relationship between Lib and Anna emerges as a highlight in reader reviews. Common criticisms include the slow pacing of the first half, with some readers reporting it took 100+ pages to become invested. Several reviews mention frustration with the protagonist Lib's initial judgmental attitude. Some found the ending rushed compared to the deliberate early chapters. "The atmospheric writing transported me to 1850s Ireland," notes one Goodreads reviewer, while another states "the medical and cultural details felt authentic but the story dragged." Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (164,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 (22,000+ ratings) LibraryThing: 4.1/5 (1,200+ ratings)

The Essex Serpent by Sarah Perry This gothic tale combines scientific skepticism with folklore through the story of a Victorian widow investigating reports of a mythical beast in an English coastal town.

The Sealed Letter by Emma Donoghue Based on a Victorian divorce scandal, this historical novel explores the role of women, truth, and social expectations in nineteenth-century Britain.

The Great Believers by Rebecca Makkai This narrative moves between 1980s Chicago and contemporary Paris while examining faith, loss, and the boundaries between life and death.

The Good People by Hannah Kent Set in nineteenth-century Ireland, three women attempt to cure a child through folk medicine and ancient beliefs when modern medicine fails.

The Ghost Map by Steven Berlin Johnson This work of historical non-fiction follows a doctor and a priest investigating the source of a cholera outbreak in Victorian London while challenging medical and religious beliefs of the time.

🌟 Though "The Wonder" is a work of fiction, it was inspired by nearly 50 real-life cases of "fasting girls" from the 16th-20th centuries – young women who claimed to survive without food for extended periods. 🍀 The novel's setting in 1850s Ireland occurs just after the devastating Great Famine (1845-1852), which adds historical depth to the story's themes of food, faith, and survival. 📚 Author Emma Donoghue conducted extensive research into 19th-century nursing practices to accurately portray Lib Wright's medical training under Florence Nightingale. 🎬 The book was adapted into a critically acclaimed Netflix film in 2022, starring Florence Pugh as Lib Wright and directed by Sebastián Lelio. 💭 Donoghue wrote the first draft of "The Wonder" while also working on the screenplay for "Room," her previous novel-turned-film that earned four Academy Award nominations.